What if the doctor refuses to follow my directions?
In most states care providers can refuse to honor advance directives
(directives communicated by the agent or a living will) for moral or religious
reasons. Some of those states require that care providers remove themselves
from the case and transfer care of the patient to someone who will honor the
patient's request. But in practice, a healthcare professional's refusal to
honor an advance directive can cause a new set of issues. For example, it may
be difficult to arrange the patient's transfer to another physician or
A refusal to stop treatment that stems from a misunderstanding of the law or
medical ethics might be resolved by supplying the provider withthe correct
information. In other instances a care provider may feel that the patient's
choice conflicts with his or her professional responsibilities or personal
moral values. Many medical facilities have ethics committees that might help to
resolve disputes over patients' wishes. In extreme cases legal action may be
Each issue, WebMD the Magazine's "Health Highlights" focuses on a national health theme for the month with expert tips, reader comments, and eye-catching factoids. September is Healthy Aging month – follow these tips to stay at your peak!
1. Get moving
Exercise regularly to maintain a healthy body and brain.
2. Stay social
Take a class, volunteer, play games, see old friends, and make new ones.
3. Bulk up
Eat beans and other high-fiber foods for digestive and heart health...
A possible way to avoid such conflicts is to speak about the patient's
wishes with the physician when you discuss other issues related to the
patient's condition or treatment. This discussion will give you an opportunity
to find out something about the physician's perspective and values related to
end-of-life decision making. If the physician is unresponsive when issues about
patient's treatment wishes are raised, or expresses an unwillingness to honor
the patient's wishes, you may want to transfer the patient to someone else's
care before a conflict arises.
If I withdraw as the agent, can anyone else make decisions for the patient?
If the patient has appointed an alternate agent, you can withdraw and the
alternate agent will become the legal decision maker. If there is no appointed
alternate agent, the outcome varies among the states.
In some states, law sets forth a procedure for making decisions for patients
who do not have designated decision makers. The law usually designates someone
from a ranked order of those who can make decisions, for example, the legal
guardian, spouse, majority of adult children, and so forth.
However, in some states there is no provision for decision making in the
absence of an appointed agent unless the patient's own wishes are clearly
known. If the patient's wishes are not known, treatment may have to
WebMD Medical Reference from the National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization