The key to health may be knowing when to listen, when to talk.
May 15, 2000 -- In his engaging and acclaimed new book, Second Opinions:
Stories of Intuition and Choice in the Changing World of Medicine, Jerome
Groopman, MD, tells seven life-and-death stories that illustrate the dangers of
not listening or not speaking up. Groopman is the Recanati Professor at Harvard
Medical School, a staff writer for The New Yorker, chief of experimental
medicine at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston, and, as his writing
reveals, a vulnerable human being.
He begins his book with the cautionary tale of his own pigheadedness as a
young patient. He then recalls his hesitance to speak up as the parent of a
sick infant -- a reticence that almost led to his son's death from an
intestinal obstruction. And in the course of a tale about saving a patient's
life, he confesses his own medical mistake years earlier that resulted in a
patient's death. In his only Internet interview, Groopman responded to
questions from WebMD openly and with a research scientist's eye for detail.
Recommended Related to Health Insurance & Medicare
The journey toward health care reform reached a historic milestone March 22 when the House approved legislation that would extend coverage to 32 million more Americans and impose new restrictions on the insurance industry.
Here are answers to some frequent questions about what reform will mean to consumers:
WebMD: While each of the seven stories you tell in your book stands on its
own, was there one main point you were trying to communicate?
Groopman: Yes. The point is really in the story about our son who almost
died because of two sequential medical misjudgments. That was a transforming
experience for both my wife and me. As the years went by, I thought about it
more and felt it was very important to recount that story (and the others in
the book) to give both patients and doctors the courage to come closer in terms
WebMD: The stories seem to be about there being a time to talk and a time to
listen. You said your experience as a patient with a ruptured disc in search of
a quick fix -- because you were determined to run in the Boston Marathon --
taught you more about listening than you learned in medical school. Where did
you go wrong?
Groopman: I told that story about myself because I was a very bad patient. I
was young and cocky and really determined to "doctor shop" until I
found an orthopedic surgeon who told me, glibly, exactly what I wanted to hear.
I've regretted that decision for the last 21 years. It changed my life, and not
for the better, in terms of functioning. I would have benefited from listening
more closely to the other physicians who offered more conservative approaches
and also from having someone with me [in the exam room], because when you're a
patient, you're confused and frightened. I was in pain and I made a mistake.
to Ask for a Second Opinion)
WebMD: It's pretty hard when you're young and healthy to imagine you can be
permanently changed by not listening. Is there a way to teach people this?