Pets May Protect Children From Allergies
Fluffy and Fido may look innocent, but they are at the heart of a
controversy among allergy specialists on the influence pets have on a child's
risk of developing allergies.
A growing body of evidence suggests that pets in the home may actually have
a protective effect against developing pet allergies, at least for the first
seven years of life, researchers at the recent annual conference of the
American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology say.
Researchers at the Henry Ford Health System in Detroit and the Medical
College of Georgia in Augusta followed more than 700 children living in two
upper-middle-class communities north of Detroit from the time of their birth
through age 6 or 7. More than half of the families had either a dog or a cat
from the time the child was born.
At regular intervals the investigators analyzed the children's blood for
substances called antibodies that trigger allergic reactions in the body.
Antibodies are in turn triggered by allergens, substances in the environment
that provoke allergic reactions. Symptoms of allergic reactions include
difficulty breathing, facial swelling, and hives.
Researchers took skin-reaction tests that showed whether the children were
sensitive, or allergic, to dog or cat allergens. They also collected data on
the children's exposure to cigarette smoke and home and day-care environments,
and they measured allergen levels in household dust and air samples.
By the age of 6 or 7, children who had lived with a dog or cat since the
first year of life were significantly less likely to be allergic to dogs and
cats. They even found that children who had a dog were less allergic to cats,
and children who had a cat were less allergic to dogs. The association between
a pet and decreased allergy risk was especially strong in first-born
"Our conclusion is that having a cat or dog in the house for some reason
puts you at lower risk of having the indicators for allergy," says lead
investigator Christine Cole Johnson, PhD, MPH. Johnson is director of Cancer
Epidemiology Prevention and Control at the Josephine Ford Cancer Center in
Detroit. Somehow, exposure to a dog or cat in early childhood protects a child
against developing pet allergies.
Speaking at the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology, Cole
warned that this protection did not seem to extend to asthma: Approximately 10%
of the children in their study developed that condition.
At the same conference, allergist Richard F. Lockey, MD, reported on a
41-year-old man with asthma who experienced two severe allergic reactions, one
nearly fatal, while washing his pet ferret. He also developed hives on his
abdomen when the animal touched his skin. Lockey and his colleagues at the
University of South Florida and the VA Hospital in Tampa, Fla., found that
extracts of ferret hair and urine elicited positive test responses from people
known to have multiple allergies, including allergies to cats and dogs.