Skip to content

    Arthritis Health Center

    Font Size

    Is Less-Invasive Hip Replacement Best for You?

    Finding the right surgeon and asking the right questions can help determine if minimally invasive hip replacement is right for you.

    Wanted: Better Evidence continued...

    "The number of patients with dramatic benefits such as walking without [crutches or a cane] the day after surgery are very few, with surgery done by a very small subset of surgeons," Brian McGrory, MD, chairman of the expert panel that wrote the AAHKS advisory, tells WebMD.

    What's more, the long-term outcomes remain unknown, says Daniel J. Berry, MD, professor and chairman of the department of orthopaedic surgery at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn.

    The goal of joint replacement is to achieve "a long-lasting, well-functioning implant" that is free of complications, he points out.

    "It's important for patients to understand that if there is an advantage to minimally invasive methods -- and I emphasize 'if' -- it will be for only a very short period of time, a few weeks or at most a few months," Berry tells WebMD.

    "And after that, conventional methods are likely to be just as good or possibly better."

    Hip Replacement Debate Heats Up

    With release of the new research on complications from minimally invasive hip replacement, critics have turned up the heat.

    "Is it justifiable to take patients through this learning curve?" asks Thomas S. Thornhill, MD, a professor at Harvard Medical School who uses the technique himself. "I'm troubled."

    If only "miraculous" surgeons can get results, which "us lesser mortals can't," then the typical orthopaedic surgeon in the community "shouldn't be doing this operation," says Richard Rothman, MD, professor and chairman of orthopaedics at Thomas Jefferson University in Philadelphia.

    For most people, the operation of choice right now is a standard hip replacement.

    "We've been too polite to educate the public appropriately," says Rothman, who has taught and performed total hip replacements for decades.

    "I'd go to a place that was convenient for me, where I could have good follow-up, and have a good rapport with the surgeon," says McGrory. "What I really want is a pain-free, stable hip that lasts a long time."

    Hip Replacement Questions for Your Surgeon

    If you're considering minimally invasive hip replacement, here are some questions to discuss with your surgeon.

    What is minimally invasive hip replacement? Do you use one incision or two? How long is/are the incision(s)?

    Today on WebMD

    Mature woman exercise at home
    Hint: Warming up first is crucial.
    feet with gout
    Quiz yourself.
    woman in pain
    One idea? Eat fish to curb inflammation.
    senior couple walking
    Can you keep your RA from progressing?
    xray of knees with osteoarthritis
    close up of man wearing dress shoes
    feet with gout
    close up of red shoe in shoebox
    two male hands
    Woman massaging her neck
    5 Lupus Risk Factors