Should Age Determine Prenatal Testing?
Study Challenges Long-Held Practice of Reserving Tests Mostly for Women 35 and Older
Jan. 22, 2004 -- A new study challenges the popular notion that only pregnant women age 35 and older should get prenatal testing.
Study researchers say that age shouldn't be the primary criteria in whether or not to be tested. No matter the woman's age, prenatal diagnostic testing is cost-effective under these criteria, they explain in this week's issue of The Lancet.
Since prenatal testing guidelines were first developed in the 1970s, age has largely dictated which expectant mothers get fetal screening tests that detect birth defects but also boost miscarriage risk.
No matter their overall health, most pregnant women age 35 or older are advised to get an amniocentesis or CVS test to determine whether their developing baby has Down syndrome or another chromosomal abnormality. But these tests are usually not done on younger women, unless they are deemed to be at high risk of birthing a child with Down syndrome or another problem.
The reason: Risk of these defects steadily increases with later-age pregnancy, with 35 being the long-designated age at which these invasive diagnostic tests seem to make sense. At this age the risk of procedure-related miscarriage risk is almost equal to the chance that a child will be born with Down syndrome, according to the authors. They also say that the cost of offering aminocentesis would be offset by the savings associated with preventing the birth of an infant affected by Down syndrome.
"We're not pushing for or discouraging against amniocentesis or CVS testing for pregnant women," Miriam Kuppermann, PhD, tells WebMD. "What we're saying is that women should be allowed to choose for themselves whether or not to undergo testing -- regardless of their age."
Traditionally, one of these diagnostic tests has been routinely recommended for women who are pregnant at age 35, but not for younger women. Largely, this results from the fact that before age 35, the risk of birthing a baby with Down syndrome is almost 1 in 1,000; at 35, it jumps to almost 1 in 400 and increases with each year. Additionally, there is some type of chromosomal abnormality in about half of pregnancies that end in miscarriage, reports the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.