Study Shows Having Baby at Home Is Safe
But Pediatrician Says It's Tough to Be Prepared for Emergencies at Home
Night and Day continued...
Falcao, who is not a nurse, has attended at about 100 home births in and
around Silicon Valley. She tells WebMD that it has become more difficult over
the past few years to find partner physicians to work with her if the mom ends
up needing medical care. She says insurance companies in California have
adopted a policy of terminating the malpractice insurance of doctors who back
up home-birth midwives.
She estimates that just under a third of her first-time moms will end up
giving birth in a hospital due to complications, but the rate is much lower
among women who have already had babies.
A total of 12% of the women who planned home births in the newly published
study ended up being transferred to hospitals due to complications.
Most Midwife Births in Hospitals
According to CDC figures, the number of births attended by midwives
increased steadily between 1975 and 2002, rising from just under 1% in the
mid-'70s to 8%.
But the vast majority of these births were attended by nurse midwives in
hospitals or birthing centers. There are no good figures on home births in the
United States, but in a 2000 report the CDC estimated that the numbers are
The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) represents
more than 46,000 women's health care physicians. The group opposes home
"Labor and delivery, while a physiologic process, clearly presents
potential hazards to both mother and fetus before and after birth," the
ACOG position statement on home birth states. "These hazards require
standards of safety that are provided in the hospital setting and cannot be
matched in the home situation."
Pediatrician Concerned About Home Births
In a 2002 study, Seattle pediatrician Jenny W. Pang, MD, MPH, and colleagues
from the Washington School of Public Health reported that babies delivered at
home have nearly twice the risk of dying shortly after birth as those born in
the hospital. The researchers reviewed more than 7,500 home births and 14,000
hospital births in Washington between 1989 and 1996.
Pang tells WebMD that the risk was still very small, with just 0.33% of
babies born at home dying, compared to 0.17% of hospital-born babies. And she
says she does not believe the findings reflect a difference in competence
between attending physicians and midwives.
"Whether you are talking about a physician, a nurse-midwife, or a
[non-nurse] midwife, the thing that matters most is how much experience they
have," she says. "My reservations about home births have less to do
with who is in charge than they do with location. You can't possibly be set up
for all the emergencies that may arise in a home setting."