Skip to content

    Health & Pregnancy

    Font Size

    Are Repeat C-Sections Safer Than Natural Birth?

    Natural Birth After a C-Section Shown to Be Slightly Riskier Than Repeat Surgery, but Complication Rate Low for Both
    WebMD Health News
    Reviewed by Louise Chang, MD

    March 13, 2012 -- Planned repeat cesarean section is linked to healthier outcomes among mothers and babies compared to vaginal birth after cesarean, or VBAC, in a new study from Australia.

    Death and serious health issues associated with either delivery method were rare.

    But women in the study who had planned surgical deliveries experienced fewer serious bleeding issues compared to women who planned to have VBAC deliveries, and their babies were about half as likely to die or suffer serious health problems around the time of birth.

    VBAC Rates Declining

    One in three babies born in the United States is delivered by cesarean section, and the rate of vaginal deliveries in women who have had C-sections continues to decline.

    Many ob-gyns no longer offer VBAC deliveries to their patients, and many insurers no longer pay for them.

    While the Australian study suggests that planned repeat cesarean sections may be safer than labor in women who have had previous C-sections, it isn’t that simple, says Catherine Y. Spong, MD, of the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development.

    Repeat C-sections carry their own risks, and those risks rise with each pregnancy.

    “The big take-home for me is that we need to prevent the first cesarean delivery whenever possible,” she tells WebMD. “Clearly the safest delivery method for both mother and baby is an uncomplicated vaginal delivery. The problem is, we don’t know which patients will have uncomplicated deliveries.”

    2 Stillbirths in Planned VBAC Group

    The Australian study included 2,345 pregnant women who had one previous delivery by C-section and were considered candidates for VBAC.

    Planned C-section deliveries were scheduled for 1,108 women and VBAC deliveries were planned for the remaining 1,237 women.

    But less than half (43%) of the women who chose to labor ended up having vaginal deliveries. The rest had elective C-sections or had emergency surgical deliveries due to complications.

    There were two unexplained stillbirths in the planned vaginal delivery group. There were no infant deaths among babies born to women who had scheduled cesarean section.

    The rate of fetal or infant death or serious health issues prior to hospital discharge was 2.4% in the planned VBAC group, compared to 0.9% in the planned C-section group.

    The researchers concluded that while the actual risk for both forms of delivery was quite small, elective repeat C-sections were associated with significantly lower risk for both mother and baby.

    Pregnancy Week-By-Week Newsletter

    Delivered right to your inbox, get pictures and facts on
    what to expect each week of your pregnancy.

    Today on WebMD

    hand circling date on calendar
    Track your most fertile days.
    woman looking at ultrasound
    Week-by-week pregnancy guide.
    Pretty pregnant woman timing contaction pains
    The signs to watch out for.
    pregnant woman in hospital
    Are there ways to do it naturally?
    slideshow fetal development
    pregnancy first trimester warning signs
    What Causes Bipolar
    Woman trying on dress in store
    pregnant woman
    Woman looking at pregnancy test
    calendar and baby buggy
    dark chocolate squares