Skip to content

    Autism Spectrum Disorders Health Center

    Font Size

    Vaccine Court Rejects Autism Claims

    Vaccine Court: No Merit to Claims That Thimerosal in Vaccines Contributed to Autism
    WebMD Health News
    Reviewed by Louise Chang, MD

    Feb. 12, 2009 -- The federal "vaccine court" has rejected claims that either the measles/mumps/rubella (MMR) vaccine or thimerosal in vaccines caused children's autism.

    The ruling is a major setback for the more than 5,000 cases in which families claim that the mercury-based thimerosal -- a preservative no longer in wide use in vaccines -- or the MMR vaccine itself caused their children's autism.

    "We didn't just lose, we didn't get to first base," Curtis Webb, lawyer for one of the families involved in today's decision, tells WebMD.

    The vaccine court -- shorthand for the Office of Special Masters of the U.S. Court of Federal Claims -- oversees all claims for compensation due to vaccine-related injuries.

    The three cases addressed today by the vaccine court were picked as test cases by a panel of lawyers representing all the families with vaccine-related autism claims. The main issue in all three test cases was whether thimerosal-containing vaccines and/or the MMR vaccine can cause autism.

    The decision, in all three cases, is no. The court formally rejected arguments that either the MMR vaccine or thimerosal caused the children's autism.

    The three separate decisions by the court's "special masters" were not close.

    "To conclude that [autism] was the result of [this child's] MMR vaccine, an objective observer would have to emulate Lewis Carroll's White Queen and be able to believe six impossible (or, at least, highly improbable) things before breakfast," wrote Special Master Denise K. Vowell.

    The vaccine court reviewed huge amounts of scientific evidence, including tens of thousands of pages of medical records and scientific literature and testimony from scores of medical experts.

    Today's ruling is a legal decision and not scientific proof. Even so, the court firmly rejected arguments that thimerosal or MMR vaccine causes autism.

    "I find that it is extremely unlikely that any of [this child's] disorders were in any way causally connected to her MMR vaccination, or any other vaccination," writes Special Master George L. Hastings, Jr. [Italics in original.]

    Not the End, Lawyer Says

    Though disappointed, Webb isn't ready to give up.

    "We [will] file a motion for review within 30 days," Webb says.

    Today on WebMD

    girl at window
    Symptoms within the first 2 years of a child’s life.
    boy playing a violin
    Where do they fall on the spectrum?
    Mother and daughter indoors playing
    Play therapy may undo the disorder in at-risk babies.
    preschool age girl sitting at desk
    What causes this rare condition?
    High Functioning Autism And Asperge Syndrome
    Gluten Free Diet Slideshow
    Mother and daughter indoors playing
    man on bicycle
    girl at window
    Mother hugging teenage son
    Understanding Rett Syndrome
    Home Care Tips

    WebMD Special Sections