Saving the Breast From Cancer: Only for the Rich?
WebMD News Archive
May 11, 2000 (Washington) -- Poor, less-educated women with breast cancer
are more likely to lose a breast to the disease than are their more affluent
counterparts, a new study shows. Wealthy, college-educated women are more
likely to undergo a procedure called lumpectomy.
A lumpectomy is when only the tumor is removed, leaving the breast
essentially intact, and the patient then undergoes radiation or chemotherapy
treatments afterward. The cancer has to meet certain criteria (such as small
size) to be eligible for this treatment. Mastectomy is removal of all the
breast tissue and sometimes the muscle underlying the area.
To discover "what factors influence a woman's choice to undergo
lumpectomy or mastectomy," lead researcher Lisa F. Baron, MD, and
colleagues at The Medical University of South Carolina in Charleston surveyed
almost 680 breast cancer survivors who'd been treated at North Carolina and
South Carolina centers between 1995 and 1998. She presented the results of the
study at a medical conference here this week.
The women answered questions about their age, income, marital status, and
education level at the time of diagnosis, their family history, whether they'd
ever been pregnant, how their cancer was detected, and where they'd received
their treatment information. "We asked if they talked to their friends or
clergymen, who they confided in, and what treatment their physician had
recommended," says Baron.
Of the 406 women who responded, almost 350 had undergone mastectomy and 58
had undergone lumpectomy. Those patients were matched up for age at the time of
diagnosis, marital status, family breast cancer history, and prior
Of all the variables, says Baron, "what made a difference was patient
education and income." Compared to women who'd had a mastectomy, those
who'd undergone lumpectomy were wealthier, were more likely to be college
graduates, and tended to be married at the time of diagnosis.
According to Baron, there are a number of possible explanations.
Lower-income, less-educated women may not have easy access to transportation or
affordable child care, or have the job flexibility necessary to allow the six
weeks of daily, tiring chemotherapy treatments that go along with the
lumpectomy procedure. Mastectomy, on the other hand, is quicker and does not
require additional resources.
What's more, she says, these women may not know that under certain
circumstances, "lumpectomy does not lessen the odds of long-term
survival." In this study, when women were given a choice of treatment, 31%
decided on mastectomy, and 33% opted for lumpectomy, "although breast
conservation is often better in the long term for the patient's feelings about
herself as a woman," says Baron. "These women need to know ... that
choosing lumpectomy will not affect their life expectancy."
Whether the disparity is a matter of transportation and other logistical
details, insufficient information, or a combination, Baron tells WebMD that
education is key. "We need to pay very special attention when it comes to
teaching low-income and less-educated women about the benefits of breast
conservation treatment," she says.
The fact that everyone who participated in this study is a survivor
"should empower women to take charge of their health," says Baron. In
addition to doing monthly self exams and getting regular mammograms, she says,
"if you've been diagnosed with breast cancer and you're scared, if things
like transportation or child care or job concerns are keeping you from getting
treatment -- you need to communicate that to your health care