Skip to content

    Breast Cancer Health Center

    Font Size
    A
    A
    A

    Lumpectomy Still Good Choice for Women

    But New Breast Cancers Can Develop That May Require Breast Removal
    By
    WebMD Health News

    July 14, 2003 -- For women with early-stage breast cancer, lumpectomy still seems the best treatment choice. However, women should be checked regularly for signs of new cancers, researchers say.

    Their study appears in the August issue of Cancer, published online today.

    Lumpectomy, which involves surgical removal of the cancer, some surrounding tissue and usually some of the lymph nodes in the underarm, has increasingly gained acceptance as an effective alternative to mastectomy in treating early-stage breast cancer. Lumpectomy preserves as much of the breast anatomy as possible and is followed by radiation therapy to reduce the chance of recurrence.

    However, questions remain about the long-term effect of radiation therapy on surrounding normal tissue when compared with mastectomy, writes lead researcher Matthew M. Poggi, MD, a researcher at the National Cancer Institute (NCI).

    In fact, other studies have indicated that though survival rates for these procedures are similar, women who opt for lumpectomy have higher rates of recurrence, with some cancers developing 20 years or more later, writes Poggi. However, those cancers have been treated successfully.

    His current study supports those findings.

    Survival Rate Still Excellent

    In it, he describes the results of an NCI study conducted between 1979 and 1987. The study involved women diagnosed with early-stage breast cancer -- cancer that has not spread beyond the breast.

    Of the 237 women, one-half underwent modified radical mastectomy and one-half had lumpectomy and radiation therapy. All the women were followed for an average of 18 years.

    "There were no detectable differences" in overall survival rates among the women, reports Poggi. The data:

    • 63% of women who had lumpectomy were still disease free 18 years later, compared with 67% of women who had mastectomy.
    • In the lumpectomy group, 22% developed breast cancer in the treated breast during the follow-up period or up to 20 years after treatment; 59% of those women were treated successfully with mastectomy.
    • Women in both groups had similar overall survival rates 18 years later, with 59% of the mastectomy patients and 54% of the lumpectomy patients still living.

    Get Checked Regularly

    This study helps allay concerns that cancer from radiation treatments could develop many years afterward, Poggi writes. However, 20 years may not be sufficient to follow up on that possibility.

    Bottom line: Although there was no overall difference in survival, women who choose lumpectomy should be monitored closely for any recurrences, he says.

    Today on WebMD

    Breast Cancer Overview
    From mammograms to living after treatment.
    Dealing with breast cancer
    Get answers to your questions.
     
    woman having mammogram
    The 3 latest tips to know.
    woman undergoing breast cancer test
    Most abnormalities aren’t breast cancer.
     
    Resolved To Quit Smoking
    VIDEO
    Breast Cancer Treatments Improving
    Article
     
    Woman getting mammogram
    Article
    Screening Tests for Women
    Article
     
    serious woman
    Article
    Pink badge on woman chest to support breat cancer
    QUIZ
     
    what is your cancer risk
    Article
    breast cancer survivors
    Article