New Clues on Breast Cancer Decline
Increases and Drops in Breast Cancer Rates Tied to HRT Use
WebMD News Archive
Does HRT Cause Breast Cancer? continued...
One theory is that menopausal hormone therapy fuels the progression of
already existing precancerous cells within the breast, just as antiestrogen
treatments like tamoxifen slow the growth of existing ER+ tumors.
“We have known that these cancers respond to hormones used for treatment,”
Glass says. “What we didn’t know was that the use of hormones for other reasons
may encourage the growth of these cancers.
So does menopausal hormone therapy actually cause breast cancers or just
promote their growth?
The answer isn’t clear, but University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center
professor of biostatistics Donald A Berry, PhD, says the latter scenario is
In an editorial accompanying the study, Berry noted that if HRT caused ER+
breast cancers, the decline in cancers as women stopped the therapy would be
far more gradual than what was seen in 2003.
“It is conceivable that some of these cancers would never show up without
this fuel, but we don’t know that,” he tells WebMD.
Another unanswered question, Berry says, is whether the recent decline in
breast cancer incidence will translate into a large drop in cancer deaths.
Since the drop was largely confined to more highly treatable
hormone-sensitive breast cancers, he says it may not.
“It is quite possible and indeed likely, that the [decline] we are seeing
will have minimal if any effect on breast cancer mortality,” he says.
The decision to use HRT is made in collaboration with your doctor and is
based on risk factors, such as personal medical history and family history and
benefits. If the decision to use HRT for menopausal symptoms is made, most
menopause groups now recommend using HRT in the lowest effective dosage for the
shortest time possible to treat hot flashes and other menopause symptoms.
- If you’re in the early stages of breast cancer and need support, you can
find other women like you on WebMD's Breast Cancer: Friend to
Friend message board.