Skip to content
My WebMD Sign In, Sign Up

Breast Cancer Health Center

Font Size

Are Benefits of Annual Mammograms Overstated?

Analysis of 50 years of clinical data adds to controversy over who should be screened, how often

continued...

"Mammography does appear to save lives, but it's not as effective as people have thought," said Dr. Otis Brawley, chief medical officer for the American Cancer Society.

Unlike the USPSTF, the American Cancer Society still suggests that women start yearly mammograms at age 40.

But, Brawley said, "there's a second line to the recommendation that doesn't get quoted in the media."

The "second line" says doctors should also tell women about the limitations and potential harms of screening, so they can make an informed decision.

"I've long been worried that we're overselling the benefits of mammography," Brawley said. He stressed, though, that "even though the benefit is less than promised, there's still a benefit."

Brawley also noted that 20 years ago, mammography might have had a bigger impact. Breast cancer treatment has improved so much that earlier detection through screening may not make as much of a difference as it did two decades ago, he explained.

Meanwhile, the American College of Radiology and the Society of Breast Imaging issued a joint statement Tuesday that questioned the validity of some of the data that was used in the Harvard review, and both groups reiterated their support of the value of annual mammograms for women aged 40 and older.

And the president and CEO of Susan G. Komen had this to say about the latest finding:

"We know mammography's shortcomings. We're very concerned about the potential for overdiagnosis and overtreatment," Judith Salerno said in a statement issued Tuesday. "But it's the most widely available test that we have for now.

"UItimately, we need more accurate screening tools. Komen is investing in research to develop those," Salerno added. "But until those tools are widely available, our position is that a woman should have access to a mammogram if she and her doctor think she should have one."

Where does this leave women?

"There's no one-size-fits-all here," Keating said, adding that screening decisions require a "more nuanced discussion."

Giving women some numbers can help, according to Keating. For example, the average 40-year-old American woman has a 1.5 percent chance of developing breast cancer over the next 10 years. If she has a mammogram in each of those years, her risk of a false-positive result is 61 percent, Keating's team estimates.

False-positive results lead to needless follow-up tests and, for some women, anxiety.

On the other hand, Keating noted, many women are not put off by the possibility of a false-positive and would rather have the test.

"I tell my patients it's important to understand that mammography isn't perfect," Keating said. "It has limitations. It misses some cancers, and some women will die of breast cancer even if they have a mammogram," she explained.

"Some patients say, OK, I'll delay or have them less often," Keating said. "Some decide they still want to have one every year."

In the same issue of the journal, a second review found that life expectancy should be the biggest factor when it comes to whether women aged 75 and older should get screening mammograms. Unless the woman is expected to live for at least another decade, the harms outweigh the benefits, the researchers from the University of California, San Francisco, and Harvard Medical School concluded.

1|2

Today on WebMD

Breast Cancer Overview
From self-exams and biopsies to reconstruction, we’ve got you covered.
Dealing with breast cancer
Get answers to your questions.
 
woman having mammogram
Experts don’t agree on all fronts, but you can be your own advocate.
woman undergoing breast cancer test
Many women worry. But the truth? Most abnormalities aren’t breast cancer.
 
Breast Cancer Treatments Improving
VIDEO
Resolved To Quit Smoking
SLIDESHOW
 
Woman getting mammogram
Article
Screening Tests for Women
SLIDESHOW
 
ovarian cancer overview slideshow
SLIDESHOW
serious woman
Article
 
what is your cancer risk
HEALTH CHECK
10 Ways to Revitalize Slideshow
SLIDESHOW