June 3, 2008 -- A watchdog group called on the FDA to ban artificial food dyes because of concerns they may be linked to behavior problems in some sensitive children.
The Center for Science in the Public Interest wants eight artificial colorings to be pulled off the market in favor of natural food dyes now in growing use in Europe and elsewhere. The eight dyes include Yellow 5, Red 40, Blue 1, Blue 2, Green 3, Orange B, Red 3, and Yellow 6.
Another analysis looking at several separate trials estimated that food dyes contribute to hyperactivity disorders in sensitive children. "At the very least, regulators should track consumption of [artificial food colorings]," concludes the study, which was published in 2004 in Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics.
The studies helped lead Britain's Food Standards Agency in April to recommend a ban on six artificial dyes. The European Union's food safety agency has dismissed the studies as too broad to draw any solid conclusions about the safety of food dyes.
The Grocery Manufacturers of America, an industry group, pointed to the EU decision as evidence that food dyes are safe.
"Based on these findings, there is no need for consumers to alter their purchasing and eating habits and they and their children can safely enjoy food products containing these food colors," Robert Brackett, the group's chief science officer said in a statement.
David W. Schab, MD, a Columbia University psychiatrist who conducted the study, says parents could achieve much of the therapeutic effect of hyperactivity drugs like Ritalin by cutting artificial colorings from the diets of sensitive children.
Other experts agree. In a newly published editorial appearing in BMJ, pediatrics professor Andrew Kemp, MD, of the University of Sydney, called for removal of food additives from the diet to be part of standard initial treatment for kids with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
Jacobson said if the FDA won't ban the dyes, they should require foods to carry warnings cautioning about the potential dangers.
FDA officials were not available to comment on the group's petition in time for publication.