Vaccine Refusal Raises Chickenpox Risk
Kids Are 9 Times More Likely to Get Chickenpox if They Don't Get Vaccinated
Jan. 4, 2010 -- Chickenpox cases have dropped by about 80% in the U.S. since
a vaccine to prevent the disease became available almost 15 years ago, but many
parents still reject immunization because of concerns about vaccine
Now new research confirms what public health officials have long known:
Children whose parents refuse to allow chickenpox vaccination are at increased
risk for getting the disease.
From a group of close to 90,000 children enrolled in a Colorado health plan,
researchers from the Kaiser Permanente Institute for Health Research in Denver
identified 133 children who got chickenpox and compared them to 493 children
matched for sex, age, and length of enrollment in the health plan who did not
get the disease.
They found that children were nine times as likely to get chickenpox, also
known as varicella, when their parents refused to have them vaccinated.
Overall, about 5% of chickenpox cases were attributable to vaccine
Seven children with chickenpox in the study (5%) were not vaccinated due to
parental objections, compared to three (0.6%) without a history of
"Many parents refuse the varicella vaccine because they think of chickenpox
as a mild illness, but this is not necessarily true," study investigator Jason
M. Glanz, PhD, of Kaiser Permanente tells WebMD.
"Before the vaccine there were 100 deaths and 10,000 hospitalizations a year
due to varicella. It can cause very severe illness in newborns and adults and
in children with compromised immune systems."
CDC: Chickenpox Vaccine Is Safe
The CDC recommends that all healthy children who haven't had chickenpox
should receive two doses of chickenpox vaccine, with a first dose optimally
given between 12 and 15 months of age and a second dose given between 4-6 years
of age (or at least three months later than the first dose).
Vaccination is also recommended for older children and adults who have no
evidence of prior infection with the varicella zoster virus (VZV), which causes
The most common reactions from the vaccine are soreness or swelling at the
site of the injection, or a mild rash or fever.
According to the CDC, more serious reactions such as seizure and pneumonia
are very rare.
But several studies suggest that the VZV vaccine is the most commonly
refused childhood vaccine.
It is not exactly clear how many parents choose not to have their children
"The best estimates we have suggest that about 1% to 2% of parents refuse
vaccinations for their children, and there is evidence to suggest this number
may be growing," Glanz says.
Infectious disease specialist William Schaffner, MD, says while the number
of parents who reject all vaccines for their children remains small, the number
with specific concerns about vaccines and vaccination schedules appears to be
Schaffner is professor and chairman of preventive medicine at the Vanderbilt
University School of Medicine in Nashville, Tenn.
"The pediatricians I talk to are telling me that the time they spend
addressing parents' concerns about vaccinations has grown exponentially over
the past five years," he says.