Breast Cancer: Preventive Mastectomy

In hopes of avoiding future disease, some women at very high risk of developing breast cancer elect to have both breasts surgically removed, a procedure called bilateral prophylactic mastectomy. The surgery aims to remove all breast tissue that potentially could develop breast cancer. Preventive breast cancer surgery also may be considered if a woman has already had breast cancer and is therefore at increased risk for developing the disease again in either breast.

Is Prophylactic Mastectomy Effective?

A recent study suggests that prophylactic mastectomy may reduce the risk of breast cancer by as much as 90%. However, results vary widely. In some studies, women had prophylactic mastectomies for a variety of reasons, such as pain, fibrocystic breast disease, dense breast tissue, cancer phobia or a family history of breast cancer. Some women still developed breast cancer even though they had their breast tissue removed. But in most studies, patients did not develop breast cancer after prophylactic mastectomy. However, many of these patients would not have been considered high-risk for developing cancer.

Some experts have argued that even for high-risk women, prophylactic mastectomy is inappropriate because not all breast tissue can be removed during a surgical procedure. To understand why, we need to know what comprises breast tissue and where cancer originates.

Where Does Cancer Form?

Breast cancers may develop in the glandular tissue of the breast, specifically in the milk ducts and the milk lobules. These ducts and lobules are located in all parts of the breast tissue, including tissue just under the skin. The breast tissue extends from the collarbone to the lower rib margin, and from the middle of the chest, around the side and under the arm.

In a mastectomy, it is necessary to remove tissue from just beneath the skin down to the chest wall and around the borders of the chest. However, even with very thorough and delicate surgical techniques, it is impossible to remove every milk duct and lobule, given the extent of the breast tissue and the location of these glands just beneath the skin.

Who Should Have a Prophylactic Mastectomy?

Does this mean that every patient should consider breast cancer prevention surgery? The answer is clearly no. The decision to proceed with prophylactic mastectomy is an individual decision. Such factors as an estimation of individual breast cancer risk, the ability to monitor the patient for early breast cancer and, most importantly, the patient's concerns and feelings need to be considered in making this decision.

According to the American Cancer Society, only those women who are at very high risk of breast cancer should consider surgery. This includes women with one or more of the following risk factors:

• mutated BRCA genes.
• previous cancer in one breast and a strong family history of breast cancer.
• history of lobular carcinoma in situ (LCIS).

Prophylactic mastectomy should only be considered after you've received the appropriate genetic and psychological counseling to discuss the psychosocial impacts of the procedure.