The findings come from an analysis of studies comparing new technologies to traditional methods for monitoring and controlling blood sugar.
The studies find that old-fashioned insulin injections control blood sugar just as well as insulin pumps. But most studies find that people get better results by combining the pumps with new blood sugar-monitoring devices.
Patients who used continuous glucose monitors to automatically track blood sugar had better blood sugar levels than people who used finger stick testing alone. However, the two methods were equally effective at keeping blood sugar from dropping to dangerously low levels.
Insulin pumps were no more effective for controlling blood sugar than self injection in most studies, but people tended to prefer the pumps over giving themselves shots many times a day.
And people who used insulin pumps with coordinated, real-time continuous monitoring devices achieved better blood sugar control than people who use finger-stick testing and shots alone.
"When we compared the new to the old, we saw a much greater improvement in glucose control when the newer devices were used together," study author Sherita Hill Golden, MD, MHS, of Baltimore's Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, tells WebMD.
More Options for People With Insulin-Dependent Diabetes
About 26 million Americans have diabetes, in which the body fails to produce enough insulin to control the amount of sugar in the blood.
New technologies have given people with diabetes who use insulin more options to manage their disease, but it has not been clear whether this new, more expensive technology truly improves people's health.
"Health professionals and their diabetic patients need objective information when making decisions about use of these technologies that may be expensive or heavily marketed," Golden and colleagues write in the July 10 issue of the journal Annals of Internal Medicine.
Their analysis included data from 33 trials comparing continuous glucose monitoring with insulin pumps to conventional ways of monitoring and controlling blood sugar levels in children, teens, and adults.