Biology Dictates Diet Success
Low-Glycemic-Load Diet Best for High-Insulin Secretors
WebMD News Archive
May 15, 2007 - Why do certain diets work for some people and not for others?
Blame biology, a new study suggests.
The study shows that obese people using a weight loss strategy called the
low-glycemic-load diet lost nearly 13 pounds over a year and a half -- but only
if their bodies secreted high amounts of insulin in response to sugars.
Obese high-insulin secretors who tried a low-fat diet lost only 2.5 pounds.
On the other hand, people who were low-insulin secretors lost the same amount
of weight -- a little more than 4 pounds after a year and a half -- on
low-glycemic-load and low-fat diets.
"The low-glycemic-load diet was effective for a lot of the individuals
who were high-insulin secretors and who previously had challenges losing weight
and keeping it off," study researcher Cara B. Ebbeling, PhD, co-director of
obesity research at Children's Hospital Boston, tells WebMD.
Ebbeling, David S. Ludwig, MD, PhD, and colleagues report the findings in
the May 16 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association.
No ‘One Size Fits All’ Weight Loss Diet
Ebbeling, Ludwig, and colleagues randomly assigned 73 obese men and women
aged 18 to 35 either to a low-glycemic-load diet or to a low-fat diet. All of
the study participants got intensive counseling and motivational support for
Their main finding was that a person's success with a particular weight loss
diet might have more to do with biology than with willpower.
"The key question is, 'Why do some people succeed on a low-fat diet
while others fail?'" Ebbeling says. "The usual explanation is that
people who succeed just have more willpower. This study indicates that
differences in insulin secretion are at least part of the reason why people
don't succeed at a low-fat diet. Such people may do better on a
The most important thing about the Ebbeling/Ludwig study is that it
challenges the "one size fits all" mentality that surrounds weight loss
diets, says Madelyn Fernstrom, PhD, founder and director of the Weight
Management Center at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center.
"What is newsworthy about this study is it offers a biological
explanation for the observation that different people respond differently to
the same diet," Fernstrom tells WebMD. "There is a subgroup of people
who squirt out a lot of insulin in an exaggerated response to sugary foods --
and maybe these are people who respond much better to a low-glycemic-load
Low-glycemic-load diets are often called "slow-carb" diets. The idea
of these diets is to avoid starchy and/or sugary carbohydrates -- such as white
potatoes or white rice -- and to eat lots of fruits, nonstarchy vegetables,
legumes, and whole grains.
It's an offshoot of high-fiber diets that cut cholesterol and heart disease
risk, says David J.A. Jenkins, MD, PhD, DSc, director of the clinical nutrition
and risk factor modification center at St. Michael's Hospital, Toronto, and
professor of nutritional sciences at the University of Toronto.