Skip to content

    Supplement No Help for Cancer, Heart, Stroke -- but Increases Heart Failure Risk

    March 15, 2005 -- Vitamin E harms more than it helps, a large study shows.

    Vitamin E is a powerful antioxidant, thought to clear the body of harmful oxygen compounds called free radicals. By soaking up free radicals, researchers hoped that vitamin E would prevent cancer and heart disease.

    That doesn't happen, finds Eva Lonn, MD, of McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario, and colleagues. Lonn led a seven-year-long, international study that enrolled thousands of people at high risk of heart disease. The findings added to suspicions raised by prior studies: Vitamin E isn't worth it.

    "We saw definitely no benefit, and at least the potential for harm," Lonn tells WebMD. "Now the overwhelming evidence from many studies is that vitamin E provides no protection against heart disease, stroke, or cancer."

    Lott and colleagues report their findings in the March 16 issue of The Journal of the American Medical Association.

    Vitamin E Harm: Slight but Significant Risk

    Lonn's study enrolled nearly 10,000 people with heart disease, peripheral artery disease (also commonly called poor circulation, a disease of blood flow through the arteries) or diabetes. This put them at very high risk of heart attack and stroke. All were over age 55. Half got high-dose vitamin E -- 400 IU every day (about 400 milligrams) -- and half got fake pills that looked the just the same.

    After four years, those who took vitamin E had no fewer heart attacks, strokes, cancers, or cancer deaths.

    But many experts wondered whether that was long enough for vitamin E to help. So Lonn and colleagues extended the study for another three years.

    "But we saw no benefit at all on cancer and no benefits for heart outcomes -- a composite measure of heart attack, stroke, and heart death," Lonn says.

    Unexpectedly, they did see one difference. Patients taking vitamin E had significantly more heart failure.

    Vitamin E was linked to a 13% higher risk of heart failure and a 21% increased risk of hospitalization for heart failure. That's a pretty small risk. But since the vitamin did no good at all, it's a risk not worth taking.

    "If there is no benefit from taking something, you shouldn't take even a small risk of harm," Lonn says.

    There is no need to worry if you take a multivitamin that contains recommended amounts of vitamin E. But Lonn advises people not to take pills containing high amounts (400 IU or more) of vitamin E.

    Healthy Recipe Finder

    Browse our collection of healthy, delicious recipes, from WebMD and Eating Well magazine.

    Top searches: Chicken, Chocolate, Salad, Desserts, Soup

    Healthy Recipe Finder