Skip to content

    Health Care Reform:

    Health Insurance & Affordable Care Act

    Supreme Court Set to Hear Pivotal HMO Case


    In addition to the Herdrich case, it's estimated there may be as many 20 class action lawsuits pending against health insurers, not unlike those that have beset the tobacco and gun industries. However, the legal basis isn't product liability, but rather conspiracy and racketeering. "The [racketeering] claims are nonsense," says Gabardi.

    Congress is also considering legislation that would allow patients to sue their health plans in state court for failure to provide care. A Congressional conference committee is trying to reconcile two different bills passed last year -- the House version would empower patients with the right to sue.

    Health plans are shielded from this practice by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). ERISA cases are usually argued in federal court, and patients are unable to collect punitive damages.

    "I think there's an assault on the industry. I think the politicians who have participated in it are now becoming confronted with the reality that if we go away, working families will have few alternatives," American Association of Health Plans' president Karen Ignani tells WebMD.

    Paul Ellwood, MD, the man credited with coining the term "HMO" says managed care providers are "plenty worried" about the increasingly litigious atmosphere. "If these organizations are practicing medicine, they should be responsible for the medicine they practice. But at the same time, I think that some of the anti-HMO emotion could destroy our ability to be practical in the amount of medical care that we give to people," Ellwood tells WebMD.

    While critics say the Herdrich case strikes at the very heart of an HMO's ability to provide quality care at a lower price, Larry Gostin, JD, a specialist in health law at Georgetown University, says that managed care is facing increasingly tough challenges from the courts, and the industry must respond. "If they structure their contracts in ways that mean that patients don't come first, then, yes, [sue the HMOs]. But all they need to do is restructure their financial incentives, which is not impossible," Gostin tells WebMD.

    Meanwhile, vocal HMO reformers on Capitol Hill like Rep. Greg Ganske, MD (R, Iowa) see the Supreme Court case as an opportunity to advance their own agenda. In Ganske's case, that means an arbitration mechanism that could avoid costly punitive damages, with litigation as a last resort.

    "If the Supreme Court rules ... in the plaintiff's favor on this, then the HMOs are going to come back to Congress and say, 'You've got to do something about this,'" Ganske tells WebMD. "There are just so many egregious cases where the HMO has injured a patient, and it was never the intent of Congress to give that kind of legal immunity to a health insurer."

    Today on WebMD

    stethoscope on person's chest
    Your Marketplace choices,
    How not to waste money on health care.
    man in cafe looking at computer
    Finding low-cost health insurance.
    doctor showing girl a stethoscope
    Get the facts on health insurance.

    Latest Health Reform News

    Loading …
    URAC: Accredited Health Web Site TRUSTe online privacy certification HONcode Seal AdChoices