Hatton's conclusion, "This is the most complex and prescriptive privacy law ever."
However, Goldman says it's a baseline that can be reached, and she says the AHA's numbers "are based on misinformation and distortion." She says the government's own estimates show that by factoring in efficiencies gained through new transaction standards, there will actually be a net savings to the industry of $12 billion over a 10-year span.
The American Association of Health Plans, the Health Insurance Association of America, as well as the AHA and the American Medical Association all issued statements urging the government to redraft the proposal.
"It will affect the patient-physician relationship in the sense that there will be more paperwork burdens. ... We want more time for patient care, not more time for paperwork," AMA Trustee Donald Palmisano, MD, tells WebMD. He also says that ironically the rule won't keep medical information away from marketers, because they're not directly covered by a health statute.
But avoiding the privacy issue also has a price. Goldman says that as many as up to 20% of Americans avoid the medical system for fear that their confidential information will be revealed to an insurer or an employer.