Skip to content

    Health Care Reform:

    Health Insurance & Affordable Care Act

    Day 2 at the Supreme Court: Individual Mandate and the 'Broccoli Possibility'

    WebMD Health News

    Health Reform Faces Intense Supreme Court Scrutiny

    March 27, 2012 -- There was high drama at the high court today.

    Attorneys for the Obama administration and opponents of the Affordable Care Act squared off in the Supreme Court this morning over the law’s most controversial provision: the mandate to obtain health insurance coverage or pay a penalty.

    U.S. Solicitor General Donald Verrilli Jr., the attorney for the federal government, told the justices that the health care reform law merely regulates the timing of how Americans purchase health care. The mandate, Verrilli said, is acceptable under the Constitution’s Commerce Clause, which gives lawmakers the power to regulate commerce.

    Attorneys for officials from 26 states and the National Federation of Independent Business, which are challenging the Affordable Care Act, described the mandate in more dire terms, saying it is unprecedented and unconstitutional for Congress to force someone to buy something and penalize them if they don't.

    The Broccoli Argument

    Justice Stephen Breyer called that scenario of unlimited federal power the "broccoli possibility.” That phrase refers to the argument that the individual mandate could open the doors for Congress to require Americans to eat broccoli.

    The humor of a broccoli mandate aside, Justice Anthony Kennedy -- the potential swing vote on the court -- said the case has momentous implications.

    “Here the government is saying that the federal government has a duty to tell the individual citizen that it must act,” said Kennedy, “and that is different from what we have in previous cases, and that changes the relationship of the federal government to the individual in a very fundamental way."

    'Can You Create Commerce in Order to Regulate It?'

    The arguments on each side of the legal battle are familiar ones. What was different today was how the justices forced the attorneys to defend their positions from their opponents’ strongest attacks.

    Within a few minutes of Verrilli’s presentation, Justice Kennedy asked him, “Can you create commerce in order to regulate it?”

    Verrilli replied that the act does not create commerce, but rather regulates an existing health care marketplace that at one time or another will include everyone, whether they like it or not.

    Today on WebMD

    stethoscope on person's chest
    Your Marketplace choices,
    How not to waste money on health care.
    man in cafe looking at computer
    Finding low-cost health insurance.
    doctor showing girl a stethoscope
    Get the facts on health insurance.

    Latest Health Reform News

    Loading …
    URAC: Accredited Health Web Site TRUSTe online privacy certification HONcode Seal AdChoices