Skip to content

Health Care Reform:

Health Insurance & Affordable Care Act

Healthcare Cost Comparisons? Colorado Is Trying

WebMD News from Kaiser Health News

By Eric Whitney

Sat, Feb 15 2014

Coffee is important to many of us, but let’s say your coffee maker breaks.  Finding a new one is as easy as typing “shop coffee maker” into your browser.  Voila – you’ve got models, prices and customer reviews at your fingertips.

But say you need something less fun than a coffee maker, like a colonoscopy. Shopping for one of those is a lot harder. Actual prices for the procedure are almost impossible to find, and Bob Kershner says there's huge variation in cost from one clinic to the next.

“You see the range is from $2,800 down to just about $400,” he says, pointing to a computer screen displaying some colonoscopy prices in Denver.

Kershner works for a nonprofit called CIVHC, which is starting to make health care prices publicly available in Colorado. His boss, Edie Sonn, says knowing prices can change the whole health care ball game.

“Knowledge is power,” she says. “None of us have had much information about how much health care services actually cost, and how much we're getting for our money. And an all payer claims database gives you that information, so you can become an empowered consumer.”

Colorado is one of eleven states that are starting to make a lot of health care prices public. It's taken years. An "all payer claims database" is step one in Colorado. It’s basically a giant shoebox that aims to collect a copy of every receipt for a health care service in a given state. Since doctors and hospitals generally don't tell people how much services cost beforehand, the best way to figure it out is to get receipts from the parties that pay the bills: insurance companies, Medicaid and Medicare, mostly.

The more that information is public, Sonn says, the more people will “vote with their feet” and migrate away from high-cost providers.

However, turning this price information from eye-crossing spreadsheet rows to consumer-friendly formats is hard. Colorado's effort has taken years. Laws had to be passed to get insurance companies to send in their claims data - the receipts for what they're paying - and sorting through all the information is a lot tougher than organizing a pile of paper receipts in a shoebox.

Loading …
URAC: Accredited Health Web Site TRUSTe online privacy certification HONcode Seal AdChoices