Skip to content

Health Care Reform:

Health Insurance & Affordable Care Act

Small Businesses Warn Patients' Rights Means More Uninsured

Not all insurance horror stories deal with patients.

WebMD Feature

July 31, 2001 (Washington) -- Not all insurance horror stories deal with patients. At a Capitol Hill news conference Tuesday, representatives of the small business community expressed their fears that a patients' bill of rights could force them to increase premium costs for their employees or drop coverage altogether.

"We volunteered to provide health coverage for employees. We didn't volunteer to get sued," said Joe Corey who employs 225 people in his four Italian restaurants. Corey is particularly concerned with the bill that's already passed the Senate; it would provide HMO patients broad rights to sue their health plan in state and federal court.

With a vote on patients' rights now expected in the House on Thursday, employer liability remains one of the major stumbling blocks to a legislative compromise. Reports indicate that President Bush has come close to a deal with Rep. Charlie Norwood (R-Ga.) who has been a key backer of a plan favored by the Democrats which the President has threatened to veto, mainly because of the question of excessive lawsuits.

Both the White House-backed plan and the one sponsored by Democrats and moderate Republicans have a number of features in common, including greater access to the emergency room and treatment by specialists, and external review of treatment issues. Still to be determined, though, is the contentious issue of when patients can sue their HMO for denial of care and what the limits of those awards should be.

It appears that a final bill would keep larger employers who self-insure and manage their plans out of state courts where they would face the most potential liability. Meanwhile, the small business representatives complain that a federal court "carve out" to protect large companies is unfair to them.

Even though the major bills now contain a "dedicated decision maker" that would assume liability in the event of legal action, many businesses aren't convinced they would be protected. Rep. Ernest Fletcher (R-Ky.) says the bigger question is liability itself, which would hit small business people at the same time medical costs are going up.

"The thing that scares us the most is holding the employer liable. We go through a middleman, or broker. We have absolutely nothing to do with the decisions that are made for healthcare, and to sue us for it could be devastating," says Bob Richard, who owns a small chain of convenience stores based in Ohio.

A large volume of similar tales was presented at the event that brought together key backers of the White House plan, including Fletcher. He told reporters that he was now "95%" in sync with the tougher measure written by Norwood and Rep. John Dingell (D-Mich.). However, he still has some serious concerns.

Your Costs

See insurance premium
costs and financial aid.

Start Here

Health Insurance

Find a plan that's right
for you.

Start Here

Your State's Insurance Marketplace

Get informed about plans, benefits and costs.

From WebMD
Loading …
URAC: Accredited Health Web Site TRUSTe online privacy certification HONcode Seal AdChoices