Study: Ablation Beats Drugs for Atrial Fibrillation
Catheter Ablation Better Than Drugs at Treating Some Atrial Fibrillation Patients
Jan. 26, 2010 -- Treating the common heart rhythm disorder known as atrial
fibrillation by destroying a small area of heart tissue using a catheter works
dramatically better than drug treatments in many patients, a new study
About 2.2 million Americans have the heart disorder, which occurs when the
two upper chambers of the heart, or atria, quiver erratically instead of
beating effectively. As a result, blood may pool and clot in the heart,
increasing the risk for stroke and heart failure.
Catheter ablation involves the use radiofrequency energy to destroy selected
heart tissue in an effort to eliminate the source of the irregular heart
In the newly published study, two-thirds of patients who had failed to
respond to earlier drug treatments had no symptoms of the irregular heart
rhythm nine months after having the catheter ablation procedure.
By comparison, fewer than one in five patients treated with drugs were free
of symptoms from atrial fibrillation.
The study appears this week in the Journal of the American Medical
“It is clear that once drugs fail, further attempts to use drug therapy are
not useful,” lead researcher David Wilber, MD, of Loyola University Chicago
Stretch School of Medicine tells WebMD. “Catheter ablation works and it should
be used early, before symptoms become persistent.”
Atrial Fibrillation: One Patient’s Story
The incidence of atrial fibrillation, or A-fib, is on the rise in the United
States as the population ages. According to the American Heart Association, as
many as 5% of people over the age of 65 have the condition.
Unlike many other heart rhythm disturbances, pacemakers are not commonly
used to treat A-fib.
People with A-fib may have no symptoms or they may feel chest pain, heart
palpitations, dizziness, shortness of breath, and fainting. The abnormal heart
rhythm is often intermittent at first, but it may become persistent.
Diane Clark, 64, had lived with A-fib for 3 1/2 years before having the
ablation procedure in December 2009 at Loyola University Medical Center.
“During a bad week, I would have three to five episodes,” she tells WebMD.
“When I stood up, I was so dizzy I thought I would faint.”
The busy chairwoman of a Chicago-area high school English department, Clark
was hesitant to have catheter ablation until June of last year.
“I had a nasty fall after waking up at 4 in the morning with A-fib,” she
says. “I went to get more medicine to calm my heart and the next thing I knew I
was on the floor of the bathroom wedged between the toilet and shower. That
really frightened me, and I don’t frighten easily.”
Her procedure took four hours, and recovery took about a week. Clark was
back at work in two weeks and she hasn’t had an A-fib episode since. She has
much more energy than before the catheter ablation, even though she has been
under tremendous stress.
Her mother and a close friend died unexpectedly in the weeks following her
ablation, and her husband, who has Parkinson’s disease, was hospitalized with
“I have more strength than I have had in years,” she says. “I don’t think I
could have gotten through the last few weeks without it.”