Genetic Tests Check Risk for Sudden Death
Study Shows Genetic Tests Are Cost-Effective Way to Measure Risk for Surviving Relatives
WebMD News Archive
Nov. 16, 2009 (Orlando, Fla.) -- If you have a relative who suffered sudden
unexplained death, postmortem genetic testing is a cost-effective way of
identifying mutations that may place you and other surviving family members at
increased risk for potentially fatal heart rhythm disturbances, a
new study suggests.
"Postmortem gene testing may be a better way to determine risk to relatives
than traditional comprehensive cardiac testing of first-degree relatives," says
researcher Michael J. Ackerman, MD, PhD, of the Mayo Clinic in Rochester,
Nearly 300,000 Americans a year suffer sudden cardiac death, in which a
person dies within minutes after an abrupt loss of heart function.
Genetic defects explain up to 25% to 30% of these cases, Ackerman says.
But rather than provide genetic testing to the deceased individual, the
recommended approach is to offer comprehensive cardiac testing to first-degree
relatives, he says.
For the study, Ackerman and colleagues performed postmortem testing for two
genetic heart rhythm disorders associated with sudden cardiac death on 146
people who had suffered sudden unexplained deaths. Results showed that 40
patients (27%) had one of the two mutations known to cause sudden cardiac
The researchers then performed further testing on 160 relatives of victims
who tested positive for mutations. The tests included genetic screening and
either treadmill stress
tests or electrocardiograms.
The total cost of the gene-directed exams: $6.78 million.
Then, the researchers performed the currently recommended comprehensive
cardiac testing on all relatives of the sudden unexplained death victims,
regardless of their mutation status. The cost exceeded $7.7 million.
“Use of a [genetic] autopsy to direct further testing would save almost $1
million dollars," Ackerman says.
A major obstacle to genetic testing is that insurance companies typically
don't cover the cost, while they do pay for the more expensive comprehensive
cardiac testing for all family members, he says.
Johns Hopkins cardiologist Gordon Tomaselli, MD, who moderated a news
briefing on the findings, tells WebMD that he hopes data like these will propel
more insurance companies to pay for the gene testing.
The study was reported at the annual meeting of the American Heart