Skip to content

    Lung Cancer Health Center

    Font Size

    Docs Nix Lung Scan

    WebMD Health News
    Reviewed by Gary D. Vogin, MD

    Feb. 22, 2002 -- It's now possible to detect lung cancer earlier than ever before. The downside: too many false alarms make lung-cancer screening too painful and costly.

    The new technology is called low-dose spiral computed tomography or CT. It's a great tool. Doctors would love to be able to use it for lung cancer screening. Why? New screening tools for breast, colon, and prostate cancer have increased survival over the last 25 years. Yet there's been no improvement in lung-cancer survival.

    By the time lung cancer is discovered, it's already too late for three out of four patients to be cured. Could fancy CT scans improve this grim statistic? A group of Mayo Clinic researchers tried to find out. For two years they gave spiral CT scans to 1,520 people age 50 or older who were long-time pack-a-day cigarette smokers.

    The results appear in the current issue of the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine. More than two-thirds of the people in the study learned that they had suspicious nodules in their lungs.

    "We estimate that 98% of these are falsely positive findings," study leader Stephen J. Swensen, MD, says in a news release. The authors note that nearly all high-risk patients would be expected to have at least one false-positive finding after just a few years of screening.

    CT screening did find 25 lung cancers, and 22 of them were potentially curable. That's a vastly better possible-cure rate than would be expected in cancers found during routine exams. But another seven patients had surgery to remove what turned out to be benign lesions.

    CT screening also missed lung nodules in more than one out of four patients.

    Swensen and co-workers conclude that CT screening could possibly decrease lung-cancer deaths. But they note that the "very high" rate of false alarms makes CT screening "prohibitively expensive" in terms of financial and emotional costs.

    Today on WebMD

    Xray analysis
    Do you know the myths from the facts?
    chest x-ray
    Get to know them.
    woman taking pills
    Tips to managing them.
    Lung cancer xray
    See it in pictures, plus read the facts.
    Lung Cancer Risks Myths and Facts
    Woman getting ct scan
    Improving Lung Cancer Survival Targeted Therapy
    cancer fighting foods
    Lung Cancer Surprising Differences Between Sexes
    Pets Improve Your Health
    Vitamin D
    Lung Cancer Surgery Options