Skip to content
My WebMD Sign In, Sign Up

Lung Cancer Health Center

Font Size

Many Lung Cancer Tumors May Prove Harmless

Research suggests CT scan screening might lead to needless worry, treatment in these cases

WebMD News from HealthDay

By Dennis Thompson

HealthDay Reporter

MONDAY, Dec. 9, 2013 (HealthDay News) -- Smokers who have a CT scan to check for lung cancer stand a nearly one-in-five chance that doctors will find and potentially treat a tumor that would not have caused illness or death, researchers report.

Despite the finding, major medical groups indicated they are likely to stick by current recommendations that a select segment of long-time smokers undergo regular CT scans.

"It doesn't invalidate the initial study, which showed you can decrease lung cancer mortality by 20 percent," said Dr. Norman Edelman, senior medical adviser for the American Lung Association. "It adds an interesting caution that clinicians ought to think about -- that they will be taking some cancers out that wouldn't go on to kill that patient."

Over-diagnosis has become a controversial concept in cancer research, particularly in the fields of prostate and breast cancer.

Some researchers argue that many people receive painful and life-altering treatments for cancers that never would have harmed or killed them.

The new study used data gathered during the National Lung Screening Trial, a major seven-year study to determine whether lung CT scans could help prevent cancer deaths.

The trial found that 20 percent of lung cancer deaths could be prevented if doctors perform CT screening on people aged 55 to 79 who are current smokers or quit less than 15 years ago. To qualify for screening, the participants must have a smoking history of 30 pack-years or greater. In other words, they had to have smoked an average of one pack of cigarettes a day for 30 years.

Based on the study findings, the American Lung Association, the American Cancer Society, the American College of Radiology and other medical associations recommended regular screenings for that specific segment of the smoking population.

The federal government also has issued a draft rule that, if accepted, would make the lung CT scans a recommended preventive health measure that insurance companies must cover fully, with no co-pay or deductible.

The latest projections from that same data, however, found that more than 18 percent of the cancers detected by the scans would be unlikely to do harm to the patient, said study co-author Dr. Edward Patz Jr., a professor of radiology at Duke University Medical Center. The findings were published online Dec. 9 in the journal JAMA Internal Medicine.

Patz characterized his findings as "one piece of information they were waiting for just to understand the risks and limitations of the trial and of recommending mass screening."

"When we tell patients we're going to do a test, you need to understand the risks and benefits," he said. "This is just part of the equation."

Edelman said some of the over-diagnosis can be attributed to slow-growing tumors. In other cases, however, smokers will not die of cancer because they will succumb first to emphysema, heart disease or the myriad of other major health problems caused by smoking.

Today on WebMD

lung cancer overview slideshow
SLIDESHOW
what is your cancer risk
HEALTH CHECK
 
Using GPS to Detect Lung Cancer
VIDEO
mans hand putting out cigarette
Article
 
15 Cancer Symptoms Men Ignore
FEATURE
Lung Cancer Risks Myths and Facts
SLIDESHOW
 
cancer fighting foods
SLIDESHOW
Improving Lung Cancer Survival Targeted Therapy
VIDEO
 
Lung Cancer Surprising Differences Between Sexes
VIDEO
Pets Improve Your Health
SLIDESHOW
 
Vitamin D
SLIDESHOW
Lung Cancer Surgery Options
VIDEO
 

WebMD Special Sections