Between Friends: Living Donors
It's a trend that's changing transplant medicine. More and more people are willing to donate a kidney or part of a liver - while they're still alive.
The New World of Transplant Medicine continued...
Therefore, there's no question that the surgery could potentially "do
harm" to a healthy donor. Do the donors and doctors have the right to agree
to take the risk? In today's world -- where medicine promises so much if only
organs are available -- bioethicists increasingly say yes.
"There are trade-offs, and people should have the right to weigh the
trade-offs," says Arthur Caplan, PhD, a medical ethicist and director for
the Center for Bioethics at the University of Pennsylvania. "As long as the
donor 'gets it,' they should be allowed to participate in risky things. Doctors
are not doing evil by doing small harm."
The bigger question, says Caplan, is whether transplant centers require
enough psychological counseling to make sure the donors truly understand the
full risks. In his experience, many don't, and on that point, many doctors
agree. In the August 10, 2000, issue of The New England Journal of Medicine,
editors warned that while a donor may receive the "altruistic satisfaction
of having assumed a risk in order to help another person," strict rules are
needed to ensure that people aren't pressured into becoming donors and are
fully informed of the risks.
Doing a Favor for a Friend
Although Steven accepted Michael's offer before hanging up the phone that
fateful day, he worried that his friend didn't fully understand the pain and
risks he faced by donating half his liver. He also worried that once Michael
understood the risks, he would change his mind. "I didn't want him to say
'I want to do this' and change his mind a month later when we were down to the
wire," Steven recalled after the operation.
But Michael knew what he was getting into. His friend, Ken, had given a half
of his liver to a woman Ken saw in a TV news report. "I thought, man, that
was a damn noble thing to do," Michael says. "I wondered if I would
have the courage to do something like that."
If Ken could do that for a stranger, Michael decided, he could surely do it
for a friend.