July 16, 2001 -- The poet Alexander Pope famously declared that
"the proper study of mankind is man." But just what a man is
depends on the definition you choose. Warrior? Not exclusively a male role
anymore. Leader? Yes, but women are also leaders. Hunter-gatherer? Sorry,
fellas, like the old TV commercial said, women can bring home the bacon
and fry it up in a pan.
So that pretty much leaves biology. Thank goodness we can still
count on the old sex chromosomes, Ms. X and Mr. Y, can't we? Sure, the X
chromosome has nearly 3,000 genes on it, compared with a measly two or three
dozen on the Y chromosome. But you still need a Y to make a guy, right?
Technically, yes, but it seems that even here there's some disagreement.
You walk into Home Depot or Lowe's to pick up a lightbulb. Instead, you
leave with some new flooring, a circular saw, a framing square, and big ideas
about re-tiling your kitchen.
The problem? You've never done anything more than change a lightbulb by
Growing numbers of Americans are tackling do-it-yourself home improvement
projects that once might have been left to professionals. One reason for the
shift: Stores like Home Depot, along with TV shows on networks like HGTV or the
The Human Genome Project is beginning to reveal some rather
surprising clues into the role the Y chromosome has played over time, and now
there's evidence to suggest that the X chromosome may also play a key role in
the development of sperm. In fact, says Jeremy Wang, PhD, with the Whitehead
Institute for Biomedical Research in Cambridge, Mass., some cases of male
infertility may turn out to be X-chromosome-linked disorders transmitted from
mothers to sons.
"This is like color-blindness, hemophilia -- those are
X-linked disorders; the defect is passed on by the mother. So it's possible
that male infertility could be passed on by the mother. The mother has one
defective gene, the other is on the Y type [contributed by the father's sperm],
and it could be passed on to her son, and her sons are infertile," says
Wang, a postdoctoral fellow in the laboratory of David Page, MD, professor of
Biology at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and investigator at the
Howard Hughes Medical Institute at the Whitehead, which is affiliated with
Page and colleagues have been playing gene detective, tracing
through the 300-million-year history of the Y chromosome in search of clues to
the mysteries of maleness, reproduction, and infertility, and what they found
is enough to turn inside out the conventional thinking about gender and the
contributions of mother and father.
X and Y: From Then to Now
For those who are a little rusty on Genetics 101, a brief
review may be in order. Each normal cell in the human body has 46 chromosomes:
22 pairs of autosomes -- "ordinary" chromosomes that are identical in
men and women --and two sex chromosomes. Women have two Xs, and men have one X
and one Y, and that's usually enough to make all the difference.
But 300 million years ago, when our ancestors were still
crawling around swamps on their bellies, there were no sex chromosomes.
"It turns out that once upon a time, the X and the Y were
the same. They were the two members of a perfectly ordinary pair of
autosomes," Page said at a recent Whitehead seminar. "I will argue that
300 million years ago, when we were reptiles, we had males and females, we
existed as males and females. The males made sperm, the females made eggs, but
we didn't have sex chromosomes, we only had ordinary chromosomes, and our sex
was likely determined -- whether we as a reptilian embryo developed as a male
or female -- by the temperature at which we, as an egg, incubated."