Skip to content

    Men's Health

    Font Size

    Testosterone May Undermine Flu Shot's Effectiveness

    High levels of the hormone cause fewer antibodies to be produced, researchers say

    WebMD News from HealthDay

    By Steven Reinberg

    HealthDay Reporter

    MONDAY, Dec. 23, 2013 (HealthDay News) -- The flu vaccine is less effective for men than women, and researchers at Stanford University believe they've figured out why.

    The male hormone testosterone causes genes in the immune system to produce fewer antibodies, or defense mechanisms, in response to the vaccine, they found.

    "Men, typically, do worse than women in immune response to infection and vaccination," said Stanford research associate David Furman, the lead study investigator.

    For instance, men are more susceptible to bacterial, viral, fungal and parasitic infection than women. And men's immune systems don't respond as robustly as women's to vaccinations against flu, yellow fever, measles, hepatitis and many other diseases, Furman said.

    For the study, published online Dec. 23 in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, the researchers analyzed the blood of nearly 90 adults after they received a seasonal flu shot. Men with the highest testosterone levels had the worst response to the flu vaccine across the board, Furman said.

    Testosterone is tied to classic male sexual characteristics, such as muscle strength, beard growth and risk-taking.

    "We found a set of genes in men that when activated caused a poor response to the vaccine, but were not involved in female response," he said. "Some of these genes are regulated by testosterone."

    It's testosterone's effect on these genes that causes the poor vaccine response, Furman explained.

    "This has a lot of implications for vaccine development," Furman said. Vaccine response might be better if men were given twice the dose, he suggested, or perhaps if testosterone levels were reduced.

    The whole picture isn't really clear or simple, he noted. Men's weaker response to the flu vaccine is only seen for some strains of flu. "We don't know why," Furman said.

    One expert doesn't think testosterone alone explains the difference in vaccine response between men and women.

    "There is more involved, but testosterone does affect the immune response," said Dr. Alan Mensch, medical director at North Shore-LIJ Plainview Hospital in Plainview, N.Y.

    Mensch doesn't believe it's necessary to increase vaccine doses for men. Rather, he thinks women can get by with a lower dose.

    Today on WebMD

    man coughing
    Men shouldn’t ignore.
    man swinging in hammock
    And how to get out it.
    shaving tools
    On your shaving skills.
    muscular man flexing
    Four facts that matter.
    Food Men 10 Foods Boost Male Health
    Thoughtful man sitting on bed
    Man taking blood pressure
    doctor holding syringe
    Condom Quiz
    man running
    older couple in bed