HRT: Revisiting the Hormone Decision
It's been 5 years since studies proclaimed hormone replacement therapy a danger for women. WebMD investigates today’s changes and tells you what you need to know to make the HRT decision.
Why Age Matters
Because the WHI study included women from ages 50 to 79, the initial results
were a combined tabulation of all age groups together. But Goldstein says
that when data was re-analyzed to focus on the youngest members alone, an
entirely different risk-to-benefit ratio of HRT began to
"What we discovered is that if a woman is between the ages of 50 and 55 when
she starts taking hormones, or if she begins HRT less than 10 years after she
started menopause, she has less heart disease and less death from any cause,
compared to the placebo group," says Goldstein.
Those results were published in April 2007 in the Journal of the American
Medical Association – and then again reinforced by similar research
published in The New England Journal of Medicine the following June.
Here researchers focused on younger women who had a hysterectomy, and took
estrogen alone. These results suggested that in these women HRT may also have
protective effects on the heart.
"Women who were in their 50s in the estrogen-alone trial tended to have less
coronary artery calcium if they received estrogen compared to placebo. And
coronary artery calcium is ... a strong predictor of future risk of coronary
heart disease, so these results lend support to the theory that estrogen may
slow early stages of arteriosclerosis," says researcher JoAnn Manson, MD, DrPH,
chief of preventive medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital, and professor of
medicine and women's health, Harvard Medical School, Boston.
Unfortunately, Goldstein says neither message seems to have been relayed to
women or even their doctors, and as a result many women are suffering
unnecessarily, afraid to use hormones to quell menopause symptoms in order to
protect their heart.
"We have strong evidence to show that if it is less than 10 years since you
started menopause, using HRT on a short-term basis is not likely to
harm you, and it can help you; you shouldn't be afraid," he says.
Cardiologist Nieca Goldberg, MD, agrees. "Women can sort of relax a
little -- that when they’re younger and need to go on hormone therapy because
of their symptoms, that this may not be detrimental to their heart," she
Those at risk for stroke, however, may not share this same sense of relief.
In the same April 2007 JAMA study, researchers found the risk of stroke
increased in HRT users by some 32% -- and that age or years since menopause