Skip to content
My WebMD Sign In, Sign Up

Multiple Sclerosis Health Center

Font Size
A
A
A

Controversial Treatment May Not Help MS Patients

Study appears to refute theory of blocked neck veins as cause of multiple sclerosis

WebMD News from HealthDay

Study appears to refute theory of blocked neck

By Steven Reinberg

HealthDay Reporter

TUESDAY, Oct. 8 (HealthDay News) -- A theory claiming that multiple sclerosis (MS) is caused by the narrowing of veins in the neck appears to be unfounded, Canadian researchers report.

Called "chronic cerebrospinal venous insufficiency" (CCSVI), Dr. Paolo Zamboni, from the University of Ferrara, in Italy, first proposed the idea in 2009. It soon caught the attention of many MS sufferers in search of a cure.

"He thought the main problem in MS could be the veins draining the brain and spinal cord; that these veins were blocked or congested," Dr. Anthony Traboulsee, lead researcher for the new study, said during a Tuesday morning press briefing.

The treatment, which Zamboni called the "liberation procedure," was to surgically open these veins, thereby fixing the problem and curing or at least reducing the symptoms of MS, explained Traboulsee, medical director of the MS Clinic at the University of British Columbia Hospital, part of Vancouver Coastal Health.

MS affects about 2.3 million people worldwide, according to the National Multiple Sclerosis Society. It causes inflammation and damage to the central nervous system that leads to problems with mobility, balance, sensation and thinking, depending upon where the damage occurs.

"Around the world, thousands of patients sought out this [new] treatment and reported, through social media, significant improvements," Traboulsee said. But the theory has been criticized and independent verification has been lacking, he said.

The Canadian report was published online in the Oct. 9 issue of The Lancet.

To determine the validity of the CCSVI theory and the so-called liberation treatment's effectiveness, Traboulsee and colleagues devised a series of studies.

They used two types of technology to measure narrowing of the neck veins -- ultrasound and X-ray studies following injection of a special dye. The original 2009 study by Zamboni only used ultrasound.

In the new study, which took place between January 2011 and March 2012, Traboulsee's team used diagnostic criteria similar to the earlier study on 177 participants -- 79 of whom had MS. Of the entire group, the researchers only found three adults with severely narrowed neck veins. One had MS, one was the sibling of an MS patient and one was a healthy volunteer.

"This was a big surprise to all of us. We were expecting to find many more people with this feature," Traboulsee said.

When they looked for a narrowing of more than 50 percent of the neck veins, they found 74 percent of MS patients had this narrowing.

"But again, to our surprise, we found very similar numbers of siblings, with 66 percent and with 70 percent of volunteers having these narrowings," Traboulsee said. "So, there weren't any significant differences between the three groups."

"Using the best methods available we were unable to confirm Dr. Zamboni's theory that MS was cause by CCSVI," he said. "Our conclusion was that the narrowing of the neck veins are common, and a normal finding in most people."

Today on WebMD

MS Overview
Slideshow
Woman sitting with arms on knees
Video
 
When MS Attacks
Article
Vials of pills
Video
 
Doctor and patient
Article
MS and Exercise
Article
 
Syringe
Article
MS Hormone
Article
 
Taking Control Sleep
Article
MS brain scan
Slideshow
 
Recognizing MS
Article
MS Causes
Article