When Hip Fractures Happen Again
About I of 7 Adults Who Fracture a Hip Later Have a Second Hip Fracture, Study Shows
WebMD News Archive
Oct. 12, 2007 -- Hip fractures are a repeat problem for roughly one in seven
adults who fracture a hip.
That's according to a fresh look at a study spanning more than 50 years.
The Framingham Heart Study included adults in Framingham, Mass. Participants
got checkups every two years ever since 1948, providing reams of health
research over the decades.
Forget the "heart" part of the study's name for a moment. The latest
analysis focuses on hip
fractures -- and specifically on second hip fractures -- among the study's
Second Hip Fracture
From 1952 to 2003, 481 participants fractured a hip fracture and 71
participants -- almost 15% -- had a second hip fracture during that time.
Most of the hip fracture patients were women.
Second hip fractures typically affected the hip that wasn't fractured the
Death rates rise after hip fractures. It's not that the hip fracture itself
is deadly. Rather, it's the side effects of the fracture -- including limited
activity -- that are dangerous.
In the Framingham Heart Study, about 16% of people who sustained a first hip
fracture died within a year of that initial hip fracture, compared with 24% of
those who died after a second hip fracture.
The higher death rate after second hip fractures was partly due to age.
Participants were typically 81 years old when they had their first hip
fracture and 86 when they sustained their second hip fracture, note the
They included Sarah Berry, MD, MPH, of the medicine department at Beth
Israel Deaconess Medical Center.
Hip fractures, which are most common in older adults, often happen after a
fall and are more likely in people with osteoporosis (dangerously thin
The participants didn't get bone density tests, so it's not clear how many
of them had osteoporosis.
Berry's team says more research is needed on second hip fractures. Their
study appears in the latest edition of the Archives of Internal