Skip to content

    Osteoporosis Health Center

    Font Size

    FDA Panel: Long-Used Osteoporosis Drug Too Risky

    By Fran Lowry
    Medscape Medical News

    March 7, 2013 -- An FDA panel voted to stop recommending calcitonin salmon for the treatment of osteoporosis in women who are at least five years past menopause.

    The committee voted 12-9 against continued marketing of the drug, citing lack of benefit and concerns about a cancer risk.

    Calcitonin salmon has been used by women for years to treat osteoporosis.

    In the U.S., calcitonin is marketed as Miacalcin and Fortical. It was approved in 1986 as an injection and in 1995 as a nasal spray. Calcitonin raises the amount of calcium in the bones while lowering calcium levels in the blood.

    In 2012, the European Medicines Agency recommended that calcitonin salmon not be used to treat osteoporosis after determining that the risk of developing cancer was 2.4% higher in patients using the nasal spray than in those who took a placebo.

    The nine committee members who voted to keep calcitonin on the market insisted it has a benefit, especially in the elderly and those with pain from vertebral fractures.

    The 12 panelists who voted against it thought it had little benefit that might be outweighed by the cancer risk.

    Cancer Risk Tips the Scale

    William Cooper, MD, from Vanderbilt University School of Medicine in Nashville, Tenn., says his vote to stop marketing calcitonin salmon was swayed by the risk for cancer.

    "The data that were presented to us today were not really all that compelling for benefit in the broad population of people with osteoporosis, but there is a fair amount of consistency in the data on cancer. Although it appeared to be a minor increase in risk, that really tipped the scales for me," he says.

    Michael Collins, MD, from the National Institutes of Health in Bethesda, Md., also voted to stop marketing the drug.

    "The cancer question, for better or for worse, has been raised. It's on the table. That weighed against limited [effectiveness] in the populations that have been studied. It's wishful thinking to say it could be effective in populations that haven't been studied, but there just aren't data to support this in my mind," he says.

    Today on WebMD

    Women working out and walking with weights
    Reduce bone loss and build stronger muscles.
    Chinese cabbage
    Calcium-rich foods to add to your diet.
    woman stretching
    Get the facts on osteoporosis.
    Porous bone
    Causes, symptoms, risk factors, and treatment.
    senior woman
    Woman holding plate of brocolli
    wrist xray
    Superfood for Bones
    mature woman
    sunlight in hands
    man and woman in front of xray
    woman with dumbbells