Fat in Formula for Brainier Babies?
Smarter Baby Formula
Cognitive Studies continued...
Babies consuming enriched or standard formulas from birth to
four months of age, underwent standardized tests at 18 months of age to gauge
mental and physical development. The babies who drank enriched formulas scored
seven points higher on the mental development index than those receiving
non-enriched formulas. Their average score of 105 was virtually identical to a
group of babies who had been breastfed from birth.
The children will be retested when they turn 4, and again when
they turn 9, to determine if the advantage in early brain development can be
seen later on.
In a similar study , published three years ago in The
Lancet, infants given formula with or without DHA and AA for four months
were assessed at 10 months of age. Researchers from the University of Dundee,
Scotland, found that infants who received the enriched formulas were
significantly more developed in terms of problem-solving ability.
Both of these investigations included a small number of infants
-- 44 in the U.K. and 56 in the Dallas study -- and both involved term infants.
Findings reported last August, from the largest study to date involving both
pre-term and term infants, were less than conclusive.
Toronto researchers compared brain and visual development in
more than 400 premature and 239 term infants fed either DHA and AA-fortified or
standard formulas for a year. They found that premature infants fed the
fatty-acid enriched formula had advanced brain and visual development compared
with pre-term infants fed standard formulas. The developmental advantage was
not seen in the full-term infants.
Available to all?
Those who favor adding fatty acids to commercial formulas worry
that babies who might benefit most will not have access to the enriched
products. Because the fats are costly, enriched formulas are likely to be more
expensive and may not be made available to those on government assistance. The
U.S. government, through its Women, Infants, and Children (WIC) program, is the
largest single buyer of infant formula in the world.
"If the formula companies market their products with and
without DHA -- in other words, regular and super formulas -- this could be
disastrous," Sears says. "There is no doubt in my mind that mother's
receiving formula through WIC will only be offered the cheaper formula. There
is just no scientific or ethical reason for leaving DHA out of any infant
Studies have shown that low-income women are less likely than
more affluent women to breastfeed. Because they are the largest consumers of
commercial formula, it is critical that they have access to enriched formula
when it becomes available, advocates say.
"These are working moms and, unfortunately, the work
environment is still not very friendly to breastfeeding," Levine says.
"There is no question that breast milk is best. If a mom can do it for
three or four months, we need to applaud that. But if she can't do it for six,
eight, or 12 months, then we have to give her a chance to offer her baby infant
formula that is as close to breast milk as we know how to make it."