Skip to content

    Health & Baby

    Font Size

    2 Researchers Challenge Breastfeeding Campaign

    Say Moms Who Choose Bottle-Feeding Made to Feel Inadequate
    WebMD Health News

    July 6, 2005 -- Campaigns that encourage women to breastfeed may be doing more harm than good by stigmatizing moms who choose not to breastfeed, two researchers from the U.K. claim.

    In an interview with WebMD, one of the researchers charged that the "breast is best" campaigns have turned a debate about nutrition into a "politicized moral crusade." He says women often feel pressured to breastfeed and are made to feel inadequate if they can't or won't.

    He further criticized those he calls "breastfeeding zealots" for refusing to present both sides of the issue.

    "We need a more grown-up debate about breastfeeding," says sociologist and author Frank Furedi of the University of Kent. "What is needed is a proper discussion that isn't centered on whether breast versus bottle-feeding is morally good or bad."

    Educating Moms

    Breastfeeding proponent Ruth Lawrence, MD, couldn't disagree more strongly with Furedi's claim that women who don't breastfeed are made to feel like second-class mothers. She says her own research on the subject shows just the opposite.

    Lawrence tells WebMD that the breastfeeding campaigns she helped write simply highlight the many benefits of breastfeeding.

    Lawrence is director of the Breastfeeding and Human Lactation Study Center at the University of Rochester Medical Center, and she is on the breastfeeding committee of the American Academy of Pediatrics.

    The AAP recommends that women breastfeed exclusively for six months, and continue breastfeeding for at least a year.

    "What we are doing is giving mothers the facts so that they can make their own informed decisions," she says. "For years the formula companies put out the message that bottle-feeding was just as good as breast. Now their goal is to discredit the campaigns that aim to educate women about the benefits of breastfeeding."

    Attitudes Toward Breastfeeding

    She says Furedi's research, which was funded by a group of formula manufacturers in the U.K., is just the latest effort in the pursuit of this goal.

    Furedi is a sociologist who is known for tackling a wide range of provocative societal issues. His 2002 book Paranoid Parenting urges parents to trust their own instincts rather than defer to the "experts." Furedi's 2003 book Therapy Culture challenges the value of psychotherapy as it is practiced in today's society.

    Baby's First Year Newsletter

    Because every week matters, get expert advice and facts on what to expect in your baby's first year.

    Today on WebMD

    mother on phone holding baby
    When you should call 911.
    parents and baby
    Unexpected ways your life will change.
    baby acne
    What’s normal – and what’s not.
    baby asleep on moms shoulder
    Help your baby get the sleep he needs.

    mother holding baby at night
    mother with sick child
    Chinese mother breast feeding newborn baby girl
    Track Your Babys Vaccines
    Baby Napping 10 Dos And Donts
    Mother with her baby boy
    baby in crib
    baby gear slideshow