'Abstinence-Only' Delays Sex in Young Teens
Abstinence-Only Program as Effective as Safe-Sex Education at Getting Teens to Delay Sexual Activity, Study Says
Feb. 1, 2010 -- There has been far more rhetoric than hard science in the
politically charged debate about abstinence-only education, but a new study may
help change that.
Researchers found an abstinence-only program to be as effective as safe-sex
education or a combination approach and more effective than nothing at all for
delaying the onset of sexual activity in preteens and young teens.
Two years after attending single-day sessions that focused on abstinence,
safer sex, or both, about a third of the African-American sixth and seventh
graders who took part in the study reported having had sex.
By contrast, about half of the students who took part in a day-long health
program in which sex was not discussed reported being sexually active two years
The study did not include older teens, and the abstinence program did not
stress waiting until marriage to have sex, as many ideology-based
abstinence-only interventions do.
But it was among the most rigorously designed and executed studies ever to
examine the long-term impact of an abstinence-only program, and it showed a
clear benefit in terms of delaying sex, its lead author tells WebMD.
"Contrary to what a lot of people believe, our research suggests that it is
possible for abstinence-only interventions to be effective,” says John B.
Jemmott III, PhD, of the University of Pennsylvania.
Feds Abandon Abstinence-Only
Less than a week ago, new figures were released showing that pregnancy rates
are increasing among teens in the U.S. for the first time in more than a
The announcement led many critics of abstinence-only education to blame the
rise on the proliferation of federally funded abstinence-only programs during
the Bush administration.
Concluding that there was little solid science showing that abstinence-only
education works, the Obama administration eliminated federal funding for the
programs last spring.
National Abstinence Education Association Director Valerie Huber tells WebMD
that she hopes the new research will lead the administration to rethink the
“This new study provides an opportunity for the president to adopt a course
correction in his 2011 budget and reinstate abstinence education funding,” she
A total of 622 mostly low-income African-American sixth and seventh graders
attending four inner city middle schools took part in the study. Their average
age was 12 and there were slightly more girls than boys. The oldest were 15
years old. About one in four of the participants reported ever having sexual
intercourse at the start of the study.
The students were assigned to an eight-hour abstinence-only group session,
an eight-hour sex education session emphasizing safer sex, an eight- or 12-hour
combined abstinence and safer-sex session, or an eight-hour health program,
which did not include sex as a topic.
In the abstinence-only group sessions, facilitators stressed the benefits of
abstinence and taught the preteens and teens ways to resist pressure to have
sex. The program focused on delaying sex until later in life when the
adolescent was better able to handle its consequences, rather than abstaining
from sex until marriage.