Skip to content
Font Size

Many Men Plan to Ignore PSA Test Guideline: Survey

Most say they'll still have the prostate cancer screen, despite expert panel's recommendation

WebMD News from HealthDay

By Randy Dotinga

HealthDay Reporter

TUESDAY, July 9 (HealthDay News) -- Most older American men plan to get screened for prostate cancer despite a recent recommendation that many should just skip the controversial PSA test, a new survey suggests.

The authors of a report about the survey don't reveal which side of the debate they're on, although they do write that new PSA test research suggests that its "harms outweigh the benefits."

Overall, the survey shows that "we need to do a better job of presenting both the benefits and harms of screening to all patients," said report lead author Linda Squiers, a research and evaluation methodologist with RTI International, in Research Triangle Park, N.C. "We also should explain the science behind the recommendation in plain language so everyone can understand it."

At issue is a 2012 recommendation by the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force regarding prostate cancer screening. It now says men of all ages who haven't been diagnosed with prostate cancer shouldn't get the prostate-specific antigen (PSA) test. The guideline "is based on science and rooted in the knowledge that while everyone wants to help prevent deaths from prostate cancer, current methods of PSA screening and treatment of screen-detected cancer are not the answer," the USPSTF website states.

Critics of the test say it often picks up signs of prostate cancer that are not dangerous, potentially leading to unnecessary and harmful treatment. "You'll often find disease that isn't aggressive and will never harm you. But your doctor, your wife, your relatives will put you under pressure to treat that cancer," said Andrew Vickers, an attending research methodologist at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, in New York City.

Prostate cancer treatment can lead to incontinence and impotence. But, of course, treatment can also prevent death from the disease.

Some physicians say the test is useful, and many continue to give it to patients, in some cases without consulting them.

For the new report, researchers used an online survey to tell 1,089 men aged 40 to 74 about the task force recommendation -- it was in draft form at the time of the survey in 2011 -- and ask them if they planned to follow it. None of the men had been diagnosed with prostate cancer.

The researchers then adjusted the results, adding more or less weight to certain answers in order to better reflect factors such as the nation's mix of age, race and education.

Only 13 percent of the men planned to follow the recommendation and not get a PSA test. Fifty-four percent said they'd ignore the recommendation and get tested, while one-third of men were undecided, the investigators found.

Blacks, wealthier men, those who'd had a recent PSA test, and those who were at least somewhat worried about prostate cancer were more likely to plan to get a test.

Today on WebMD

man with doctor
Symptoms, risks, treatments
man coughing
Men shouldn’t ignore
 
prostate cancer cells
What does this diagnosis mean?
doctor and male patient
Is it worth it?
 
cancer fighting foods
SLIDESHOW
15 Cancer Symptoms Men Ignore
FEATURE
 
Prostate Enlarged
VIDEO
Picture Of The Prostate
ANATOMY
 
Prostate Cancer Quiz
QUIZ
screening tests for men
SLIDESHOW
 
Prostate Cancer Symptoms
VIDEO
Vitamin D
SLIDESHOW