Skip to content
My WebMD Sign In, Sign Up

HPV/Genital Warts Health Center

Font Size

HPV Vaccine: Good News, Bad News

Vaccine Stops 2 Cervical Cancer Viruses -- but Only 'Modest' Overall Cancer Protection Seen

Different Experts, Different Opinions continued...

Gynecologist Brian Slomovitz, MD, of Weill Cornell Medical Center in New York, disagrees with Smith-McCune. He says that even with regular Pap screening, many young women will have to have precancerous cervical lesions removed -- procedures that may result in pregnancy complications.

"Cervical precancers are a big problem, and genital warts are a huge problem," Slomovitz tells WebMD. "The ultimate value of the HPV vaccine is to reduce deaths due to cervical cancer, but it is also valuable for preventing high-grade cervical lesions and genital warts."

Ault agrees with Slomovitz.

"These studies are further proof that what we recommended last year was a good idea: This vaccine should be given to women age 9 to 26," he says.

Smith-McCune insists that too many questions remain about the HPV vaccine to recommend widespread vaccination of girls and young women.

"It is important to counter the sense of urgency of vaccinating the girls with the fact that cervical cancer is not an emergency in the U.S.," she says. "Any improvement that will reduce a woman's risk of cervical cancer is a great thing. We just don't have enough data to support that yet. The studies are ongoing. We have a lot to learn about the impact of this vaccine on precancer and cervical cancer."

1|2

Today on WebMD

HPV Vaccine Future
Article
STD Overview
Slideshow
 
STD Facts Quiz
Quiz
Syringes and graph illustration
Tool
 
Sex Drive Killers
Slideshow
Genital Herpes Risks Quiz
Quiz
 
Young couple holding hands
Quiz
Herpes Vaccine Study
Video
 
Condom Quiz
Quiz
HPV Symptoms Tests
Article
 
Get The STD Picture
Feature
cancer cell
Slideshow
 

WebMD Special Sections