Study: Secondhand Smoke Fading
70% Drop in Nonsmokers With Tobacco Marker in Blood From 1988-2002
WebMD News Archive
June 7, 2006 -- Secondhand smoke exposure may be dwindling in the U.S., a new study shows.
The number of U.S. nonsmokers with detectable blood levels of cotinine -- a marker for tobacco exposure -- fell 70% from 1988 to 2002.
James Pirkle, MD, PhD, and colleagues report that finding in the June issue of Environmental Health Perspectives. Pirkle works at the CDC's National Center for Environmental Health.
A decline was seen in all age, gender, race, and ethnicity groups studied. But children and black nonsmokers had higher cotinine levels than other groups, so Pirkle's team recommends further work to curb the environmental hazard.
Snuffing Out Secondhand Smoke
Data came from 14 years of national health surveys and blood tests including nearly 30,000 nonsmokers.
Here's a look at the percentage of U.S. nonsmokers with detectable blood cotinine levels over the years:
- 1988-1991: 88% of nonsmokers had detectable blood cotinine levels.
- 1991-1994: 80% of nonsmokers had detectable blood cotinine levels.
- 1999-2000: 51% of nonsmokers had detectable blood cotinine levels.
- 2001-2002: 43% of nonsmokers had detectable blood cotinine levels.
The decline translates to a 70% drop in the number exposed from 1988 to 2002, note Pirkle and colleagues.
Cotinine only shows tobacco exposure over the previous few days, and it may fade faster or slower in some people, the researchers write.
Higher Cotinine Levels for Blacks, Children
The study tracked three racial/ethnic groups: blacks, whites, and Mexican-Americans.
Cotinine levels dropped for all groups. But blacks had higher cotinine levels than whites or Mexican-Americans throughout the study.
The reasons for that pattern aren't clear. Metabolic factors might account for some of the difference, the researchers write.
Children's cotinine levels also fell but not as much as in adults. The study doesn't pinpoint a reason for the smaller decline in kids. Children living with smokers may be exposed to tobacco at home, in cars, and in other settings, Pirkle's team notes.
Progress Made, Room for Improvement
The decline "probably reflects the substantial progress made in reducing the exposure of nonsmokers to [secondhand smoke] during this time," write Pirkle and colleagues.
The researchers call for increased intervention efforts to cut secondhand smoke exposure among kids and blacks. More work may be needed "to further encourage restrictions on smoking in the home, automobiles, and other locations when children are present," they write.