Jan. 9, 2012 -- Nicotine replacement therapies such as gums or patches may not help smokers kick the habit long-term, a new study shows.
Relapse rates of the quitters were similar during the study period, whether they used the products alone or with counseling, or they did not use them.
"Nicotine replacement therapies ... do not show any long-term effect on quitting even when combined with counseling," says researcher Gregory Connolly, DMD, director of the Center for Global Tobacco Control and professor of public health at the Harvard School of Public Health. Behavioral counseling is widely recommended, with medication, to help smokers quit.
The results of the new study are published online in Tobacco Control. The findings are at odds with clinical trials, Connolly says. The new study, however, draws from the population. It gives a more ''real world'' picture, he tells WebMD.
Smoking cessation experts and a maker of nicotine replacement therapies took issue with the findings.
Connolly does not advocate abandoning the nicotine replacement medication. Instead, he suggests understanding its use. "In the short term, what it is designed for is treatment of withdrawal," he says. "Long term, our study would not say it would prevent relapse." Better strategies are needed to prevent relapse, he tells WebMD.
Connolly followed 787 adult smokers who had recently quit in Massachusetts. The participants were interviewed over three time periods: In 2001 to 2002, 2003 to 2004, and 2005 to 2006. Of the 787 people, 480 finished the second interview and 248 the third interview.
The participants told whether they had used a patch, gum, inhaler, or spray. They told how long they used the product continuously. The recommended practice is to use the product for eight weeks, Connolly says.
Most did not use the products. For instance, at the first interview, 77% did not use them. Those who did use them did so for various time periods. At the first interview, the 33% of those who used the products did so for more than six weeks
About one-third of the quitters had relapsed at each of the three time periods.