Smallpox is one of this year's top 10 medical stories. Not bad
for a disease that's been dead for a quarter of a century.
Ironically, it was only last October that the CDC celebrated
the 25th anniversary of the last case of smallpox in the world. Smallpox is
eradicated. It stands as one of mankind's greatest achievements.
By Laura NathanDoubting your diagnosis? Read on to find out what you might really
Sometimes even the best doctors miss the mark: About 40 percent of all
mistakes that M.D.s make are misdiagnoses, says the National Patient Safety
Foundation. That's because many ailments have similar symptoms or can be
detected only with tests that your physician might consider unnecessary if he's
confident in his verdict. If you're in the know about often-confused
conditions, though, you can ask the right...
Now we fear that one of mankind's lowest acts -- terrorism --
might resurrect what 19th-century historian Thomas Macaulay called "the
most terrible of the ministers of death." We worry that Soviet Cold War-era
smallpox bioweapons might find their way into the hands of terrorists. We worry
that rogue states might somehow develop and distribute smallpox weapons. We
worry -- and now we prepare for the worst.
"The smallpox virus still exists in laboratories, and we
believe that regimes hostile to the United States may possess this dangerous
virus," President Bush said on Dec. 13. "Our government has no
information that a smallpox attack is imminent. Yet it is prudent to prepare
for the possibility that terrorists who kill indiscriminately would use
diseases as a weapon."
To this end, the U.S. already has begun an ambitious smallpox
vaccination program. About a half-million military personnel not deferred for
medical reasons must get vaccinated. Another half-million healthcare workers
will get voluntary vaccinations. After that, another 10 million healthcare
workers will be offered the vaccine. The general public eventually will be able
to choose vaccination. But unless there's an attack, no mass vaccination
program is planned.
What is the Real Threat?
For every million people who get the vaccine, thousands will
get bad reactions and one to five people will die. As Bugs Bunny used to ask in
WWII-era cartoons, is this trip really necessary?
One person dealing with some of the issues involved is Kent A.
Sepkowitz, MD, director of infection control at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer
Center and associate professor of medicine at Weill Medical College, Cornel
University, New York.
"What is threat of smallpox? I have no idea," Sepkowitz
tells WebMD. "That is the key piece. Nobody knows. That information is
missing. We are asked to take on blind faith that there is a threat and to make
a plan. It is our job to wrestle with the issues."
Samuel A. Bozzette, MD, PhD, and colleagues at RAND Health Care
and the VA San Diego Healthcare System, have looked at several plausible
scenarios for smallpox emergencies. They aren't writing science fiction. It's a
dead-serious effort to come up with cost-benefit numbers to guide public health
readiness and response.
"How likely is a smallpox bioterror attack? That is a
matter for the government to judge," Bozzette tells WebMD. "The
president says the risk of imminent attack is low. And from scenarios we've
analyzed, the range of complexity required to actually carry out these attacks
varies quite widely."
In the worst-case scenario, mass public vaccination would save
about 30,000 lives. But there's a catch. We prevent those "what-if"
deaths at a cost of about 500 very real deaths from vaccine complications.
"Our study shows that in order for there to be a
substantial advantage for mass vaccination of the public, we would need to be
facing a significant threat of a very widespread attack," Bozzette
The surprising conclusion: Mass smallpox vaccination, either
before or after a large-scale attack, won't do much net good. The reason lies
in the nature of smallpox itself.