Help for Hot Flashes
Is soy the solution to this menopausal symptom?
Heating Up the Soy Debate continued...
"I'm a strong proponent of soy, and think that menopausal
women should be incorporating soy into their diet," says Mark Messina, PhD,
MS, an adjunct professor of nutrition at Loma Linda University in Loma Linda,
Calif. "But I'm not basing that recommendation solely on its effects on hot
One of the studies most strongly supporting soy foods, says
Messina, was research from Italy published in 1998, which found a 45% reduction
in hot flashes in women consuming soy protein, compared to a 30% improvement in
the placebo group. But for every positive study, he adds, there has been
another showing no soy-related benefits.
In research published in March 2002 in the journal
Obstetrics & Gynecology, menopausal women took a daily dose of 100
mg of soy isoflavones (an estrogen-like constituent of soy that appears to be
the key ingredient easing hot flashes). These women experienced a significant
decline in their menopausal symptoms, including hot flashes, mood swings, and
sleep difficulties. But in another study in 2002 at Tufts University,
researchers found that after three months of soy supplementation, women had no
more relief from hot flashes than another group taking a placebo (dummy)
In the heat of the debate, doctors like Machelle Seibel, MD,
remain persuaded by the positive findings, and urge women to give soy a try.
"There is some good data that soy can reduce both the frequency and the
intensity of hot flashes by about 50%," says Seibel, professor of clinical
obstetrics and gynecology at the University of Massachusetts Medical School in
Worcester. "A lot of doctors feel that somehow that's not significant
enough, and would prefer that it eliminate all hot flashes. But if it can
reduce hot flashes sufficiently enough so a woman can get a good night's sleep,
that may allow her to cope better."
Mary Hardy, MD, medical director of the Integrative Medicine
Program at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles, believes that even the
positive findings for soy in some studies have shown only a modest impact on
menopausal symptoms. At the same time, she says, "some individual women say
that soy has had a tremendous effect on managing their hot flashes. However, I
wonder if it's the soy per se, or did these women also reduce the fat in their
diet, or restrict their caffeine or alcohol intake? But as part of moving to an
overall healthier diet, I think that soy can be an important component of those
While Messina tells women that soy may have a modest benefit on
menopausal symptoms, he says, "it's not the most important reason to take
soy. I think the heart benefits and the possible bone-strengthening benefits of
soy foods are more important reasons." For example, the evidence indicating
that soy can reduce blood cholesterol levels is so strong that the FDA permits
this claim on food labels.