Test Could Spare Women From Chemotherapy

Up to 40,000 Women a Year Can Safely Skip the Toxic Drugs

From the WebMD Archives

Dec.10, 2004 (San Antonio) -- A test that characterizes each breast tumor by its unique genetic fingerprint could spare tens of thousands of American women from the discomfort and misery of chemotherapy, researchers report.

About half of the 70,000 to 80,000 women diagnosed each year with estrogen-dependent breast cancer -- that has not spread to the lymph nodes -- can safely skip the drugs, says Norman Wolmark, MD, chair of the National Surgical Adjuvant Breast and Bowel Project and of the department of human oncology at Allegheny General Hospital in Pittsburgh.

"The test helps solve the real dilemma of whether to treat a woman with chemotherapy," he tells WebMD.

The test, known as OncotypeDX, which came on the market earlier this year, looks for the presence of about two dozen genes that can raise breast cancer risk. Based on their activity, women are assigned a recurrence score that determines the risk of breast cancer returning.

Studies have shown the benefit of tamoxifen and chemotherapy in women with estrogen-sensitive breast cancers that have not spread to lymph nodes. The treatment reduces the risk of breast cancer recurrence.

Yet the researchers say that since the likelihood of cancer recurring in tamoxifen-treated women is low, many women would be overtreated if chemotherapy is given to everyone.

Wolmark's first study, published online today in The New England Journal of Medicine, shows OncotypeDX can reliably predict whether a woman's breast cancer recurrence risk is low, medium, or high.

The test relies on the molecular signature of the breast cancer tissue, and based on an assigned score, can predict the likelihood of recurrence in women with estrogen-sensitive breast cancer that has not spread to lymph nodes.

The study showed that the recurrence score accurately predicted the risk of cancer recurrence, Wolmark says. Women in the low-risk category had only a 7% chance of having a recurrence at 10 years. But cancer came back in more than 30% of women who fell into the high-risk category.

Then the researchers looked at 650 women who received either tamoxifen alone or tamoxifen plus chemotherapy.

In those women with a low recurrence score, the risk of cancer spreading to other parts of the body -- what doctors call distant recurrence -- was only about 5%, regardless of whether chemotherapy was given.

But in women at high risk, there was a clear benefit: About 88% of those who got the one-two punch with chemotherapy and tamoxifen were free of cancer 10 years later, compared with only 60% of those who got tamoxifen alone.

And women at intermediate risk? The benefits are still unclear, the experts say, adding this group will be studied more in a new National Cancer Institute trial.

In the meantime, Wolmark urges eligible women to have the test. "Women should find out their risk of recurrence," he says. "Based on that risk, they can make a more informed decision about whether or not to move ahead with chemotherapy

His second study, presented here today at the annual San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium, shows that the 50% of women who fall into the low-risk category gain little if any benefit from chemotherapy.

Breast Cancer Overtreated

Current guidelines call for about 90% of women whose breast cancers are estrogen-dependent and who do not have cancer in the lymph nodes to get chemotherapy to reduce the odds of the cancer returning, says Sheila Taube, PhD, associate director of the Cancer Diagnostics Program at the National Cancer Institute. The one-size-fits-all approach leads to a huge amount of overtreatment, she says. That's where the new test comes in, says Eric Winer, MD. "His data will push us more in the direction of not giving it to these women. It's very significant information that can help us to avoid unnecessary treatment."

William Gradishar, MD, a breast cancer specialist at Northwestern University in Chicago, and a spokesman for the American Society of Clinical Oncology, agrees. He says he hopes that the new research will propel insurance companies, which have been reluctant to cover the $3,460 test, to start picking up the tab.

Christina Koenig, who faced the agonizing decision of whether to undergo chemotherapy when she was diagnosed with breast cancer several years ago, says the test could help spare women from infertility, a common side effect of chemotherapy.

When diagnosed, she says she told her doctor to "give me everything you got" to kill the cancer cells. "I thought I was a goner," she tells WebMD.

But three years later, healthy and on the verge of getting remarried, she wishes there had been another option. "I would love to be able to take this test," says Koenig, an advocate with the Y-ME National Breast Cancer Organization in Chicago. "I'd love to know that I was not at high risk and would be around to raise a child."

Show Sources

SOURCES: San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium, San Antonio, Dec. 3-6, 2003. Norman Wolmark, MD, chair, department of human oncology, Allegheny General Hospital, Pittsburgh; Chair, National Surgical Adjuvant Breast and Bowel Project. Sheila Taube, PhD, associate director, Cancer Diagnostics Program, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, Md. Eric Winer, MD, chief, breast cancer division, Dana Farber Cancer Institute, Boston. William Gradishar, MD, professor of medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago; spokesman, American Society of Clinical Oncology.
© 2004 WebMD, Inc. All rights Reserved. View privacy policy and trust info