May 2, 2006 -- Some nonhormonal therapies may help treat estrogen, doctors report in The Journal of the American Medical Association., but probably not as much as
Those findings come from a review of 43 previously published studies. The reviewers included Heidi Nelson, MD, MPH, of Oregon Health & Science University.
hot flashes are common and may be severe in menopausal women.isn't a disease. But
The studies in Nelson's review tested these therapies to treat hot flashes:
- Antidepressants. Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and serotonin norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs) such as Paxil, Prozac, Effexor, and Celexa
- Clonidine (Catapres). A blood pressure medication made in pill or patch form
- Gabapentin (Neurontin). An antiseizure medication
- Red clover isoflavone extracts
- Soy isoflavone extracts
Each treatment was separately compared with a sham treatment (placebo). The women didn't know whether they received the real treatment or placebo. They kept diaries of their hot flashes before and during treatment, which ranged in length from a few weeks to a year.
Interest Beyond Estrogen
Estrogen has long been used to treat menopausal symptoms.
"However, recent studies reporting adverse effects of estrogen, such as cardiovascular events and, raise important concerns about its use," write Nelson and colleagues. Those concerns have spurred interest in alternative treatments for menopausal symptoms.
Estrogen may still be used to treat menopausal symptoms. The FDA advises doctors to prescribe "the smallest effective dose for the shortest duration possible," write Nelson and colleagues.
Nelson's study uses the term "nonhormonal therapies" for treatments that weren't based on the hormones estrogen, progestin, progesterone, or androgen.
Isoflavones (natural chemicals in some plants, including soy), may have estrogen-like effects. For simplicity's sake, the reviewers considered isoflavone extracts to be nonhormonal therapies.
The SSRIs, SNRIs, Catapres, and Neurontin studies showed evidence of effectiveness, Nelson's team writes.
However, they were less effective than estrogen. Also, there are few published studies, and most of the studies had design weaknesses, they write.
"These therapies may be most useful for highly symptomatic women who cannot take estrogen but are not optimal choices for most women," write Nelson and colleagues.
The researchers found no sign that red clover isoflavone extracts reduced. The results on soy isoflavone extract studies were mixed.
As Nelson's team noted, some studies were higher in quality than others. Also, some trials included women who had had tamoxifen; those women may not represent other menopausal women. Hot flashes are a common side effect of tamoxifen use. Those limits may make it hard to draw definite conclusions.and were taking
The research review was "technically rigorous" but showed mixed results, and several of the drugs studied can have side effects, states a journal editorial.
The editorialists were Jeffrey Tice, MD, and Deborah Grady, MD, MPH, of the medicine department at the University of California, San Francisco. Grady also works at the San Francisco Veterans Affairs Medical Center.
"Antidepressants, clonidine, and gabapentin have been marketed for a long time but large, long-term trials (similar to the Women's Health Initiative trials of hormone therapy) are lacking," write Tice and Grady.
"Safety is a particular concern for isoflavone extracts because they contain estrogenic compounds and thus may be subject to some of the same long-term adverse effects as hormone therapy," the editorialists add.
More research is needed to understand how hot flashes work, write Tice and Grady. Meanwhile, they offer these tips for managing hot flashes:
- Dress in layers.
- Keep the home and bedroom cool.
- Know that most symptoms resolve over several months to several years.
- Understand the risks and benefits of hormonal and nonhormonal treatments.
- With all medicines or dietary supplements used as treatments, take the lowest effective dose and stop as soon as symptoms improve or end.