Skip to content

    Asthma Health Center

    Font Size
    A
    A
    A

    Asthma and Cities: Which Cities Rank Best?

    You may already know the worst cities for asthma. What about the best?
    By
    WebMD Feature

    For the past six years, the nonprofit Asthma and Allergy Foundation (AAFA) has released a list of the "Asthma Capitals" -- the worst cities for asthma. The top offenders for 2009: St. Louis, Milwaukee, and Birmingham, Ala.

    But if those are the worst cities for asthma sufferers, does that mean other cities are relatively good for people with asthma -- or at least benign?

    Recommended Related to Asthma

    Outgrowing Asthma: Is Remission Possible?

    At 14, Alyssa Flanagan’s asthma symptoms all but disappeared. Since the age of 4, she had been hospitalized a few times each year -- once in the intensive care unit - when her colds turned into coughing, wheezy pneumonias. Asthma loomed large in her life. “The simplest explanation is that I’ve outgrown it, or for some reason, there was an immune trigger that’s not present anymore,” says Flanagan, now a 30-year-old medical resident at the University of Illinois-Chicago. Flanagan says she’s aware...

    Read the Outgrowing Asthma: Is Remission Possible? article > >

    The AAFA doesn't rank the "best" cities for asthma, nor does any other medical or advocacy organization. But there are a number of factors that can make a city relatively good -- or bad -- for people with asthma. From geography to climate to pollen count, here's what you need to know about cities that are better for people with asthma.

    'Best' Cities for Asthma?

    When researchers at the AAFA rank cities for the Asthma Capitals survey, they look at the top 100 largest metropolitan areas and evaluate them on a number of criteria, including asthma prevalence, pollution levels, and pollen counts. The ten cities that ranked best in the AAFA survey are:

    • Cape Coral, Fla.
    • Seattle
    • Minneapolis
    • Colorado Springs, Colo.
    • Portland, Ore.
    • Palm Bay, Fla.
    • Daytona Beach, Fla.
    • San Francisco,
    • Portland, Maine
    • Boise City, Idaho

    But are these the "best" cities for asthma in the U.S.? No, says Angel Waldron, Marketing and Communications Manager for the AAFA, who worked on the survey.

    "We get so many people with asthma asking us, 'Where should I move?'" Waldron tells WebMD. "Unfortunately, it's just not a question we can answer. There are so many factors, and it all depends on what triggers your symptoms." A city that might be good for one person's asthma might be terrible for yours.

    Still, while there's no such thing as a best city for asthma, experts say that certain factors in cities can influence a given person's asthma -- for better or worse. Here's the rundown.

    Geography. Asthma experts say that geography can play a role in a person's asthma symptoms. Many of the cities that ranked well on the AAFA's survey were on the water. For instance, three of the ten better cities for asthma were on the coast in Florida.

    "If you're living on the water, the wind can blow away a lot of the potential allergens and irritants," says Jonathan A. Bernstein, MD, an allergist at the University of Cincinnati College of Medicine.

    Pollen counts also tend to be lower in areas on the water, says Cascya Charlot, MD, medical director of Allergy and Asthma Care of Brooklyn.

    On the other hand, cities that don't get a lot of air circulation -- for instance, those located in valleys -- can be tough for people with asthma. "Valleys can sometimes trap pollutants," says Bernstein. "The air doesn't move as freely."

    Still, while breezes from oceans and lakes may have a benefit, being on water is no guarantee for good air quality. "Other cities on the water like Milwaukee didn't score very well," says Waldron.

    1 | 2 | 3 | 4

    When Is Your Asthma Worse?

    When Is Your Asthma Worse?

    Take the WebMD Asthma assessment to get Personalized Action Plan

    Start Now

    Today on WebMD

    Lung and bronchial tube graphic
    5 common triggers.
    group jogging in park
    Should you avoid fitness activities?
     
    asthma inhaler
    Learn about your options.
    man feeling faint
    What’s the difference?
     
    Madison Wisconsin Capitol
    Slideshow
    woman wearing cpap mask
    Article
     
    red wine pouring into glass
    Slideshow
    Woman holding inhaler
    Quiz
     
    Man outdoors coughing
    Article
    Lung and bronchial tube graphic
    Article
     
    10 Worst Asthma Cities
    Slideshow
    runner
    Article