Skip to content

    Autism Spectrum Disorders Health Center

    Font Size

    FAQ: Vaccine Court Hears Autism Cases

    What's Really Going On in the Autism-Vaccines Lawsuits
    WebMD Feature
    Reviewed by Louise Chang, MD

    May 14, 2008 -- Contrary to media reports, a U.S. court has not yet issued any decisions on whether vaccines cause autism.

    It's an important issue: About 5,000 cases remain in limbo -- at the parents' request -- as the so-called Omnibus Autism Proceeding grinds on.

    This week, public hearings in the case resumed as parents of two 10-year-old boys asked the court to rule that thimerosal, a mercury-based vaccine preservative, triggered the boys' autism.

    Media interest in the case has skyrocketed since one of the parents of Hannah Poling -- one of the families involved in the case -- last March announced that they'd won.

    Indeed, in November 2007 the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) conceded that vaccination could have aggravated Hannah's underlying mitochondrial disorder and caused her autism symptoms. The HHS Division of Vaccine Injury Compensation will compensate the Polings out of its $2.7 billion trust fund, built up from surcharges paid for every vaccination covered by the program.

    So why is the court case still going on? What's at stake? Here are WebMD's answers to these and other frequently asked questions:

    • Isn't the case over? Doesn't the concession in the Poling case mean the court already has ruled?
    • Why does the federal government pay vaccine claims? Aren't vaccine companies responsible?
    • What is the vaccine court?
    • What does this have to do with autism?
    • How do the Omnibus Autism Proceedings work?
    • If the Special Masters rule that these people with autism likely suffered vaccine injury, does it mean that vaccines cause autism?
    • When will there be rulings in the cases?

    Isn't the case over? Doesn't the concession in the Poling case mean the court already has ruled?

    No. "We reiterate that this court has issued no decision on the issue of vaccine causation of autism," the case's three "Special Masters" italicized in their March 27 update on the ongoing proceedings.

    Exactly why the government decided to concede the Poling's case isn't clear. The Special Masters -- the federal judges hearing the cases -- say they "cannot provide any details concerning this matter" until the entire case is decided.

    In documents leaked to the press, government lawyers wrote that the HHS Division of Vaccine Injury Compensation "has concluded that the vaccinations [Hannah Poling received] significantly aggravated an underlying mitochondrial disorder, which predisposed her to deficits in cellular energy metabolism, and manifested as a regressive encephalopathy with features of autism spectrum disorder."

    1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

    Today on WebMD

    girl at window
    Symptoms within the first 2 years of a child’s life.
    boy playing a violin
    Where do they fall on the spectrum?
    Mother and daughter indoors playing
    Play therapy may undo the disorder in at-risk babies.
    preschool age girl sitting at desk
    What causes this rare condition?
    High Functioning Autism And Asperge Syndrome
    Gluten Free Diet Slideshow
    Mother and daughter indoors playing
    man on bicycle
    girl at window
    Mother hugging teenage son
    Understanding Rett Syndrome
    Home Care Tips

    WebMD Special Sections