FDA Criticized Over Plastic Chemical
Groups Raise Questions About the Safety of Bisphenol A
Sept. 16, 2008 -- Researchers and environmental groups attacked the FDA for concluding that a widely used plastic ingredient is safe for humans, saying the agency ignored critical studies showing potential ill health effects.
The comments came at a hearing called by the FDA to examine the science around bisphenol A (BPA). The chemical is used in hard plastic products, including some baby and water bottles, and is also used to line metal food cans.
A growing number of advocacy groups and some members of Congress have called on regulators to ban bisphenol A.
FDA: BPA Exposures Safe
A recent draft report by FDA scientists concluded that the amount of BPA humans typically consume in food and drinks does not pose a health risk.
Craig Henry, chief operating officer for the Grocery Manufacturers Association, submitted testimony at the hearing that the FDA performed a thorough, well-documented review of the available toxicological information. He said the research used a sound analytical approach and that the FDA's evaluation of the science on BPA was comprehensive.
And Steven Hentges, PhD, a scientist with the American Plastics Council, called the FDA's preliminary review "completely appropriate." He also said the industry supports more research into alleged brain and other health effects of BPA.
But several scientists have warned that the agency had discounted studies suggesting health effects in animals at BPA levels far below what regulators say are safe.
"Since these food containers are not proven safe, the FDA should not be assuring us that they are safe," said Diane Zuckerman, head of the National Research Center for Women and Families. "It does feel like there's been a rush to judgment."
BPA Critics Urge Caution
Critics pointed to five studies linking BPA exposure in brain alterations and abnormal prostate growth in rodents. Those effects were seen at levels many times lower than what the FDA concluded is safe for people.
BPA has been studied for years. But researchers struggle with the fact that most studies are in animals. A human study released today linked urinary levels of bisphenol A to an increased risk of diabetes and cardiovascular disease in adults.