Is Bottled Water Better?
Bottled water is everywhere these days. But is it really worth the extra expense?
Once upon a time, most of us could walk across a parking lot or push a
stroller down the street without a bottle of water in our hands. It doesn't
seem that way anymore.
Today, Americans consume the most bottled water of any country -- upwards of
25 billion liters a year, according to the Beverage Marketing Corporation, and
most of it on the go.
"Americans are looking for a healthful way to quench their thirst, and
bottled water is convenient, and compared to high-sugar, high-calorie choices,
it's a good choice," says Stephen Kay, vice president of the International
Bottled Water Association (IBWA).
While our thirst for bottled water seems insatiable, one question can't be
ignored: Is it really any better for us than ordinary tap water?
According to the IBWA, some 71% of bottled waters users cite quality as the
reason for buying. Quite simply, they say it's better than what's coming out of
their tap. But water safety experts say that, except in isolated situations,
this simply isn't true.
"If you repeatedly test over 100 brands of bottled water, about a third
will have a problem, but if you tested tap water that often, you will find
something similar," says Erik Olson, director of advocacy for the nonprofit
National Resources Defense Council, which in 2003 issued a comprehensive report
on the safety of bottled water.
Olson adds that with the exception of a few isolated pockets of truly bad
drinking water, most municipal systems and most bottled water sources are
fairly equal in terms of contaminants and other health and safety issues.
Need more proof of equality? Consider this: While the Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) sets standards over drinking water, and the Food and
Drug Administration (FDA) has jurisdiction over bottled water, and since the
Safe Drinking Water Act of 1974, nearly every regulation put forth by one
agency has been echoed by the other.
For its part, the IBWA says it's not trying to lead consumers to think that
bottled water is healthier -- just a more convenient choice, says Kay.
Water, Water, Everywhere
So if there is little difference between bottle and tap, is there any reason
to spend the extra dough for bottled water? Surprisingly, some experts say yes.
While all waters may be somewhat equal, the needs of all people aren't.
"In order to make an educated decision about what water to drink, you
have to look to individual vulnerabilities," says Brenda M. Afzal, RN, MS,
a specialist from the University of Maryland School of Nursing who has
consulted for the government on drinking water standards.
While contaminants found in some municipal sources won't bother the average
person, she says, some may be affected.
"Pregnant women, babies, the elderly, people who are immune-compromised,
cancer patients, or those on long-term steroidal use may benefit from choosing
certain bottled waters over their particular tap water," Afzal