How I Learned to Stop Hating My Mother
"Nobody said that life is fair." That was her favorite saying, a
stinging maternal salve in response to a daughter's tears. I know there was a
good lesson in there for me, but I wasn't ready to hear it. Instead, I thought,
No kidding. If life were fair, it would have smelled of home-baked cookies
instead of stale booze; it would have felt like a warm hug instead of a cold
"If you loved me, you'd stop drinking." That was my favorite
comeback. Fair or not, mothers were supposed to live for their kids, I thought,
and her nightly swan dive into a gallon jug of Gallo was a sloppy declaration
of rejection. I took her drinking as wholly personal, and so I tried to make
myself more lovable by overachieving in the classroom and on the soccer field;
I tried to show her how much I was hurting by turning myself into an 88-pound
skeleton. But none of that changed a thing. My mother still crawled naked up
the stairs to her bedroom, still hid glasses of vodka in cupboards throughout
the house, still chose booze over me.
And so I ran — up to Andover, down to Duke, across the country to San
Francisco. But our reckless fights — my vicious takedowns and her slurred
diatribes — carried on over the phone lines.
That's what I remember. Then my mother filled in the blanks.
One day, when my mom was growing up in a big, poor family in Alabama, her
mother, Helen — an emotionally dead woman hitched to a violently alcoholic man
— asked her if she wanted some ice cream. Helen had never asked my mother if
she wanted anything, and so my mother, craving some ice cream, decided to test
her. No, my mother said, I don't want any ice cream — hoping that Helen, for
the first time, would simply know what her daughter wanted, what she needed.
But Helen walked away, and my mother was crushed.
My mom returns to this story repeatedly as if it explains everything. If her
own mother could not meet her needs, spoken or not, what was the point in
acknowledging them, even to herself? Burying who she was and what she wanted,
losing herself to whatever role she was asked to play — such as when my father
demanded that she quit working to tend house — lit the fuse on her future
self-destruction. "Life just didn't meet my expectations," she says
with a laugh.